“Trump and his Generals” Book event, New America DC

“Trump and his Generals” Book event, Fordham University, NYC

Trump and His Generals: The Cost of Chaos
A Book Talk with Author Peter Bergen
Tuesday, December 17th, 2019

6:00-7:00PM

McNally Amphitheater, Fordham Lincoln Center, 140 W 62nd St

Peter Bergen is a journalist, documentary producer, vice president for global studies & fellows at New America, CNN national security analyst, professor of practice at Arizona State University where he co-directs the Center on the Future of War, and the author or editor of eight books, three of which were New York Times bestsellers and four of which were named among the best non-fiction books of the year by The Washington Post. The books have been translated into twenty-one languages. Documentaries based on his books have been nominated for two Emmys and also won the Emmy for best documentary.

Bergen is New America’s director of the International Security and Future of War programs. He writes a weekly column for CNN.com and is a member of the Aspen Homeland Security Group and a fellow at Fordham Law’s Center on National Security. Bergen is on the editorial board of Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, a leading scholarly journal in the field. He has testified on Capitol Hill eighteen times about national security issues.

Trump deserves to take a victory lap, CNN.com

Trump deserves to take a victory lap

Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. His new book, “Trump and His Generals: The Cost of Chaos,” will be published in December. The opinions expressed in this commentary are his own. View more opinion articles at CNN.

(CNN)President Donald Trump can certainly take a victory lap for the operation that killed the leader of ISIS, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi. Prior to his death, Baghdadi had declared ISIS a “caliphate,” as his terrorist army stormed across Syria and Iraq, seizing territory the size of Portugal and ruling over some 8 million subjects.

At Trump’s Sunday news conference, he said the ISIS leader was also personally responsible for the death of American aid worker Kayla Mueller. This appears to be the first official US acknowledgment of Baghdadi’s role in her death, as ISIS had claimed that she had died in a Jordanian airstrike in 2015. White House national security adviser Robert O’Brien told NBC the operation that killed Baghdadi was named after Mueller.
Not surprisingly, many are praising Trump’s success. Gen. Joseph Votel, who led the war against ISIS for three years under Presidents Barack Obama and Trump, and retired in March, emailed me to say, “By any measure this was an important milestone — not just for the campaign but for everyone who was victimized by ISIS under Baghdadi’s leadership. It is a psychological blow to ISIS, and it demonstrates the effort we will go to bring these terrorists to justice.”
In fact, Trump’s campaign against ISIS is one of the unalloyed foreign policy successes of his presidency. A week after he was inaugurated, Trump issued National Security Presidential Memorandum 3, which mandated an updated campaign plan against ISIS within 30 days.
And, in May 2017, Trump approved a plan to arm the tens of thousands of Kurdish forces fighting ISIS in Syria with rifles, machine guns and lightweight mortars. The Trump plan also lifted Obama-era caps on the size of the US military presence in Syria. During Trump’s first year in office, American forces in Syria would rise to 2,000 troops.
But the campaign to eradicate ISIS began two and a half years before Trump assumed office, when Obama ordered ISIS positions to be bombed during the late summer of 2014. The operation to take back Mosul, the second-largest city in Iraq where ISIS had first declared its caliphate, began in October 2016 while Obama was still in office. ISIS had also lost significant Iraqi cities, such as Fallujah, Ramadi and Tikrit, while Obama was commander in chief.
So there was certainly considerable continuity between the Obama plan against ISIS and the Trump plan, but Trump did give his military commanders the authority for taking action against ISIS so they were no longer micromanaged by the White House, as was often the case under Obama. Also, the Trump administration did away with the self-imposed limits the Obama team had put on military action in Syria.
While Trump can certainly take credit for hastening the demise of ISIS’s geographical caliphate, ultimately both presidents approached the ISIS problem in the same essential way.
First, they didn’t commit large numbers of American boots on the ground in either Iraq or Syria.
Second, using US Special Forces as trainers and advisers, they operated “by, with and through” local forces. In Iraq, those forces were the Counter-Terrorism Service and its elite Golden Division, while in Syria it was the largely Kurdish fighters of the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF).
American fighters and helicopters provided significant air support to both of these local ground forces.
ISIS once attracted an estimated 40,000 militants from around the world. The Obama and Trump campaigns against ISIS pushed that number closer to zero, since few now want to join the losing team.
The geographical defeat of ISIS in Iraq and Syria did not end the influence of ISIS, however. In a January report to Congress, the then-director of national intelligence, Dan Coats, wrote that “ISIS still commands thousands of fighters in Iraq and Syria, and it maintains eight branches, more than a dozen networks, and thousands of dispersed supporters around the world, despite significant leadership and territorial losses.”
Three months after Coats’ report was published, a Sri Lankan jihadist group inspired by ISIS carried out multiple suicide bombings across the country in churches packed with worshippers who were celebrating Easter Sunday. They also attacked luxury hotels frequented by foreigners, killing at least 250 people. It was one of the most lethal terrorist attacks since 9/11.
Any reports of ISIS’s demise were premature. And, as Gen. Votel noted to me in his email, “We will have to keep pressure on this network. I would expect there is a succession plan — we have seen this with many VEOs (Violent Extremist Organizations).”
The conditions that helped to produce ISIS remain, including the sectarianism that has torn apart countries, such as Iraq, Syria and Yemen. Also remaining are the weak or failing Middle Eastern states, such as Libya and Syria, in which jihadist terrorist organizations often thrive.
And, as we saw with the death of Osama bin Laden eight years ago, the ideology of jihadism is not extinguished with the death of any one leader.

Trump ignores his own warning in Syria, CNN.com

Trump ignores his own warning in Syria

US troops are leaving northern Syria. Here’s why 02:55

Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is completing a book about President Trump’s national security team and policies. The opinions expressed in this commentary are his own. View more opinion articles at CNN.

(CNN)Can anyone make sense of President Donald Trump’s Syria policy, other than Donald Trump?

Not much will bring senior Republicans to push back against Trump, but his decision to pull American forces out of Syria has drawn condemnation from three grandees of the GOP: Sen. Lindsey Graham, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, and former UN Ambassador Nikki Haley.
Kurds say US has betrayed them, says former US diplomat

Kurds say US has betrayed them, says former US diplomat 01:26
And for good reason: Pulling the 1,000 or so American forces out of Syria makes no sense.
Those troops are not there on a combat mission but only in an advisory role to prevent the return of ISIS and also to provide some US leverage over events in Syria, whose regime is supported by Russia and Iran.
An American pull-out also allows the Turks free rein to carry out military operations against America’s allies in the largely Kurdish Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), which were the ground troops that retook Syria from ISIS. The SDF is regarded as a terrorist group by Turkey, which has a restive Kurdish minority.
But the SDF have been the best kind of allies to the United States, losing, according to a statement from the SDF, some 11,000 soldiers fighting ISIS. This, while the US has had 17 soldiers killed in action in both Syria and Iraq during the past five years.
What is particularly odd is that we have already seen this movie before from Trump. Last December, President Trump ordered the withdrawal of the 2,000 US ground troops then in Syria.
This precipitated the resignation of the then-Secretary of Defense, James Mattis, who saw the move as an abandonment of American allies on the battlefield. Eventually, Trump was talked out of a total US withdrawal from Syria because of the possibility that ISIS might return, and because it would give Iran greater sway in the country.
If there is one key lesson learned from fighting jihadist terrorist groups in the 18 years since 9/11, it is that they thrive in weak or failing Muslim states such as Syria, and other countries where the United States has little to no presence.
The US has run a version of this play before. After the United States pulled out of Iraq, the group that later became ISIS first organized in Syria in 2011, before it invaded Iraq three years later and took over much of the country.
What is particularly odd about Trump’s policy shift on Syria is that it does exactly what Trump repeatedly warned against during his presidential campaign: it gives America’s enemies an early heads-up about US military plans.
During his campaign, Trump also had correctly critiqued the total American troop withdrawal from Iraq under Barack Obama in 2011 as helping pave the way for the rise of ISIS.
Get our weekly newsletter

Sign up for CNN Opinion’s new newsletter.

Join us on Twitter and Facebook

What Trump’s announcement on Syria also underlines is the collapse of any kind of deliberative national security process. Trump appears to make unilateral decisions surrounded by a cabinet of yes-men and acolytes because he has chased out advisers like Mattis, former National Security Adviser H.R. McMaster, former Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, and former Chief of Staff John Kelly, all of whom tended to push back against Trump’s more ill-advised decisions.
Such as a precipitous withdrawal from Syria.

This commander in chief is clueless, CNN.com

This commander in chief is clueless

Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is completing a book about President Trump’s national security team and policies. The opinions expressed in this commentary are his own. View more opinion articles at CNN.

(CNN)President Donald Trump first came to national attention with his 1987 ghostwritten bestseller, “The Art of the Deal.”

As commander in chief he has excelled in The Art of Creating a Crisis.
Exhibit A is the unfolding debacle in Turkey, where an invasion of Syria by the Turks — green-lighted, in effect, by President Trump — is exposing America’s Kurdish allies to the wrath of the second-largest military in NATO.
This came after a call Sunday between Trump and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, in which Trump said he would be pulling American forces out of northeastern Syria. Their presence there was effectively preventing a Turkish invasion.
Trump tweeted “it is time for us to get out of these ridiculous Endless Wars, many of them tribal, and bring our soldiers home.”
Then he shifted gears, threatening on Twitter to “obliterate” the Turkish economy if the Turks did “anything that I, in my great and unmatched wisdom, consider to be off limits.”
The United States doesn’t generally threaten longtime NATO allies in this manner.
Trump has taken us here before: He abruptly ordered all US troops out of Syria in December and then changed his mind when his advisers pointed out that this benefited a quartet of American adversaries: ISIS, Iran, Russia and the Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad.
As I wrote Monday in this space, can anyone make sense of President Trump’s Syria policy, other than Donald Trump?
But the fact is, Trump’s Syria policy is of a piece with his approach to other key national security challenges that he has made worse by his consistently inconsistent foreign policy.
On Iran, Trump pulled out of the nuclear agreement that was widely verified as working, and ramped up draconian sanctions on the Iranians. Then the Trump administration offered to negotiate with the Iranian regime without preconditions.
After Iran shot down a US drone in June, Trump authorized a military strike against Iranian targets that he called off at the very last moment.
When key oil facilities in Saudi Arabia were attacked last month, Trump tweeted that the United States was “locked and loaded depending on verification” of “the culprit.” He appears to have done nothing in response, despite the fact that his own administration, as well the British, French and Germans, have all plausibly identified Iran as the author of the attack.
Can anyone make sense of President Trump’s Iran policy, other than Donald Trump?
Trump ordered the surge of thousands more troops into Afghanistan in 2017, saying there would be no set timeline for their withdrawal. Two years later, he authorized negotiations with the Taliban that might have withdrawn all American troops from the country by 2020.
And then Trump abruptly canceled a meeting last month with Taliban leaders at Camp David and pronounced that the negotiations with the Taliban were “dead.”
Can anyone make sense of President Trump’s Afghanistan policy, other than Donald Trump?
Trump famously threated the North Koreans with “fire and fury” and then extolled his “love” for their dictator, Kim Jong Un. Trump also claimed that the nuclear threat from North Korea was “over” while at the same time downplaying its continued testing of ballistic missiles.
Trump’s national security adviser, John Bolton, who was pushed out of the White House last month, subsequently told an audience in Washington that North Korea had no intention of abandoning its nuclear weapons.
Can anyone make sense of President Trump’s North Korea policy, other than Donald Trump?

 

Trump’s posturing back and forth might work in a Manhattan real estate deal, but when it comes to his role as commander in chief American allies are left befuddled, not knowing where the United States stands on any given issue. And America’s enemies, who have pegged Trump as a bloviating bully who rarely makes good on his threats, take comfort.
If this is what winning looks like, I’d hate to see losing.

A year later, what Khashoggi’s murder says about Trump’s close ally, CNN.com

A year later, what Khashoggi’s murder says about Trump’s close ally

Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is completing a book about President Trump’s national security team and policies. The opinions expressed in this commentary are his own. View more opinion articles at CNN.

(CNN)A year ago, Jamal Khashoggi, a prominent Saudi writer, entered the Saudi consulate in Istanbul to obtain paperwork so he could marry his Turkish fiancée, who was waiting for him outside the building. He was never seen again.

A contributor to the Washington Post, Khashoggi, aged 59, was a critic of the Saudi regime and was living in self-imposed exile in the United States. He was murdered inside the Istanbul consulate on October 2, 2018, by a team that was dispatched from Saudi Arabia, among them associates of the Saudi Crown Prince Mohamed bin Salman — known as MBS — the then-32-year-old de facto ruler of the country.
The Saudis (and MBS himself) have consistently denied that bin Salman had any direct role in Khashoggi’s murder and instead have ascribed it to a rogue operation by overzealous subordinates. They charged 11 of them, five of whom face a possible death penalty, although given the opaque nature of the Saudi legal system little is clear about the yet unresolved case.
In November 2018, the CIA concluded — with “high confidence” according to the Washington Post — that bin Salman had ordered the murder of Khashoggi.
Khashoggi’s murder brought into sharp focus concerns about the judgment of the young prince that had percolated for years. MBS had variously entered an ongoing war in Yemen that, according to the UN, had precipitated the worst humanitarian crisis on the planet; he had blockaded the gas-rich state of Qatar, a close American ally and the site of the most important US military base in the Middle East. Domestically, MBS had also imprisoned a host of clerics, dissidents and businessmen.
At first it looked like Trump might distance himself from MBS. Less than two weeks after Khashoggi’s murder on CBS’s “60 Minutes,” President Donald Trump promised “severe punishment” for the Saudis if it was proven that they had murdered Khashoggi. Khashoggi, after all, was both a legal resident of the United States and a journalist who was contributing regularly to a major American media institution.
A month later, Trump backpedaled, citing putative massive American arms sales to the Saudis. Trump told reporters, “…it’s ‘America First’ for me. It’s all about ‘America First.’ We’re not going to give up hundreds of billions of dollars in orders, and let Russia, China, and everybody else have them … military equipment and other things from Russia and China. … I’m not going to destroy the economy for our country by being foolish with Saudi Arabia.”
Until Khashoggi’s murder, it was possible to emphasize the positive case for bin Salman, to argue that he was genuinely reforming Saudi Arabia’s society and economy. He had clipped the wings of the feared religious police in the kingdom and had given women greater freedoms, such as the right to drive and a larger role in the workplace.
Bin Salman encouraged concerts and movie theaters in a society that had long banned both and he also started to end the rigid gender separation in the kingdom by, for instance, allowing women to attend sports events.
He also promised a magical moment in the Middle East when the Arab states could deliver a peace deal with the Palestinians, while he was liberating his people from the stultifying yoke of Sunni Wahhabism that had nurtured so many of the 9/11 plotters. For many years, Washington had puzzled over whether Saudi Arabia was more of an arsonist or a firefighter when it came to the propagation of militant Islam. Bin Salman appeared to be a firefighter.
MBS also has a somewhat plausible plan for diversifying the heavily oil-dependent Saudi economy known as Vision 2030, to be financed in part by the sale of parts of the oil giant Aramco, which may be the world’s most valuable corporation with a market value that the Saudis hope is two trillion dollars.
In March 2018, MBS even visited Hollywood and Silicon Valley, where he ditched his Arab robes in favor of a suit and where he was feted as a reformer by film stars and tech industry heavyweights.
But after Khashoggi’s murder, the positive case for Mohammed bin Salman was largely submerged in the West, where he was increasingly viewed as an impetuous autocrat. In 2015, he had authorized the disastrous and ongoing war in neighboring Yemen, in which tens of thousands of civilians have been killed. He had also effectively kidnapped the Lebanese Prime Minister, a dual Lebanese-Saudi citizen, when he was on a trip to Saudi Arabia. And MBS led the blockade of his country’s neighbor, gas-rich Qatar, which continues to this day.
In addition to his arrests of prominent clerics and dissidents, Bin Salman, in a palace coup, supplanted his cousin Mohamed bin Nayef as crown prince in 2017. Famously, MBS also imprisoned 200 rich Saudis at the Ritz Carlton in Riyadh and had relieved them of more than $100 billion because of their purported corruption.
Now Bin Salman faces what may be his most difficult foreign policy challenge yet: What to do about the drone and missile attacks earlier this month against the crown jewel of Saudi Arabia’s economy, the Aramco Abqaiq oil facility, an attack the crown prince and the Trump administration have plausibly blamed Iran for. The Iranians have denied involvement in the attacks
This attack is particularly problematic for MBS, as he is also Saudi minister of defense and he has presided over a massive arms buildup, yet was not able to defend the kingdom against the missile and drone barrage that took down half of Saudi’s oil capacity, at least temporarily.
The Iranian attack also poses a quandary for President Trump, who doesn’t want the United States to get embroiled in another war in the Middle East, even though he has embraced MBS as a close ally.
On Sunday, CBS’s “60 Minutes” aired an interview with bin Salman in which he said that he hoped that Saudi Arabia could reach a “political and peaceful solution” with Iran.
One can only hope that MBS and Trump don’t launch a war against Iran, which has a large army, significant proxy forces around the Middle East and sophisticated ballistic missile systems. However, it’s hard to imagine them not responding at all since the Iranians have shown they can now attack with impunity a key node of the world’s energy markets.
Mohammed bin Salman may be able to preside over the murder of a dissident journalist in Turkey with relative ease, but there is little in his conduct of foreign policy hitherto to suggest that he will skillfully deal with the Iranians.

GSOF, Capitol Hill forum

Trump’s team of flunkies, CNN.com

Trump’s team of flunkies

Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is completing a book about President Trump’s national security team and policies. The opinions expressed in this commentary are his own. View more opinion articles at CNN.

(CNN)What a difference two years make. Back then, John Kelly, a former four-star Marine general, was Trump’s chief of staff; James Mattis, another retired four-star Marine general, was US secretary of defense; H.R. McMaster, a three-star general and war hero with a PhD, was national security adviser; Rex Tillerson, who had run ExxonMobil, one of the world’s largest corporations, was secretary of state, and Gary Cohn, the former COO and president of Goldman Sachs, was Trump’s chief economic adviser.

On a routine basis, this group would debate and even challenge President Trump.
They have all long since moved on. Trump has now surrounded himself with yes-men and is running his Cabinet like he used to run his real estate company — as a one-man show surrounded by flunkies.
Trump’s key foreign policy adviser is his son-in-law, Jared Kushner.
His key economic advisers, Larry Kudlow and Peter Navarro — who lack the stature and experience of someone like Gary Cohn — are egging on the President to ramp up his trade war with China.
His new secretary of defense, Mark Esper, is competent, but hardly has the stature of Mattis.
Acting White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney is a Trump factotum and certainly no John Kelly.
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo is “a heat-seeking missile for Trump’s a–” a former US ambassador said, describing Pompeo’s obsequious behavior in the recent New Yorker profile of the secretary of state.
CIA Director Gina Haspel is a CIA lifer who just keeps her head down.
Trump largely ignored his third national security adviser, John Bolton, a veteran of Republican administrations going back to Reagan, and eventually forced him out last week, in part because Bolton criticized the now-scrapped plan to host Taliban leaders at Camp David earlier this month.
Now comes Robert O’Brien, Trump’s pick to replace Bolton as his fourth national security adviser. Readers can be forgiven for asking: Who is he?
O’Brien is a conservative lawyer who was appointed last year to be Trump’s lead hostage negotiator at the State Department. O’Brien is favored by Pompeo, now the key player in Trump’s Cabinet.
Hostage negotiation is an area in which the Trump administration can certainly claim some real success, as the President did on April 26, 2019, when he tweeted “‘President Donald J. Trump is the greatest hostage negotiator that I know of in the history of the United States. 20 hostages, many in impossible circumstances, have been released in last two years. No money was paid.’ Cheif [sic] Hostage Negotiator, USA!”
Speaking at a news conference in March, O’Brien said: “The President has had unparalleled success in bringing Americans home without paying concessions, without prisoner exchanges, but through force of will and the goodwill that he’s generated around the world.”
During O’Brien’s tenure as lead hostage negotiator, North Carolina pastor Andrew Brunson was released from prison in Turkey, where he had been held on trumped-up terrorism charges. Danny Burch, an American oil worker kidnapped in Yemen, was released in February.
But it was astonishing to see O’Brien show up last month at the trial in Sweden of American rapper A$AP Rocky, who was charged with assault and whose cause had been touted to Trump by Kim Kardashian West.
This was an egregious misuse of O’Brien’s time and of taxpayer dollars: A$AP Rocky wasn’t kidnapped by a terrorist group or held by a despotic regime unjustly. He faced criminal charges in a closely allied, rule-of-law democracy, for which he was eventually convicted.
Meanwhile, other genuine American hostages are still in great jeopardy, such as Kevin King, a professor who was kidnapped in Afghanistan in 2016 and is seriously ill as he continues to languish in Taliban custody.
Attending A$AP Rocky’s trial in Sweden is emblematic of how O’Brien will likely spend his time at the White House: as a Trump gofer.
As Trump observed earlier this month when he mused about his pick for his next national security adviser: “It’s great because it’s a lot of fun to work with Donald Trump. It’s very easy actually to work with me. You know why it’s easy? Because I make all the decisions. They don’t have to work.”
O’Brien is about to find out how true that is.

Trump gets amnesia on Iran, CNN.com

Trump gets amnesia on Iran

Saudi-led coalition: Iranian weapons used in oil attack

Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is completing a book about President Trump’s national security team and policies. The opinions expressed in this commentary are his own. View more opinion articles at CNN.

(CNN)The leaders of Iran have reason to be confused about what President Trump’s goals are when it comes to their country. Trump pulled the United States out of the Iranian nuclear deal last year and then imposed draconian new sanctions on Iran. In June, Trump ordered military strikes against Iran and then called them off at the last minute. Trump has also said he would sit down with the Iranian leadership without preconditions, but now he appears to have reversed himself.

Trump’s posturing back and forth between aggression and conciliation might work for a real estate deal in Manhattan, but it’s quite confusing and the stakes are also much higher when you are dealing with the complex calculations of a major regional power such as Iran, which has long regarded the United States as a foe.
Forget about the Iranians — Trump’s shifting positions on Iran seem to be confusing even for members of his own cabinet. US Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin, who plays a key role in enforcing American sanctions against Iran, said last week that Trump could meet Iranian President Hassan Rouhani with “no preconditions.”
US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo made exactly the same point in June, saying the Trump administration was prepared to talk to Iran with “no preconditions.”
And in July, Trump himself said he would meet with Rouhani with “no precondition.”
But Trump seems to now have amnesia about it, tweeting Sunday, “The Fake News is saying that I am willing to meet with Iran, ‘No Conditions.’ That is an incorrect statement (as usual!).”
Trump has a history of sending mixed messages regarding his intentions toward Iran. After the Iranians shot down a US drone in June, he tweeted, “Iran made a very big mistake!” Trump approved retaliatory strikes against Iranian missile batteries and radars and then abruptly called off the operation.
In recent weeks Trump has made conciliatory statements about the Iranians. Earlier this month, Trump said he could be open to meeting with Rouhani at the UN General Assembly in New York, which begins next week.
Trump’s recently departed national security adviser, John Bolton — long an advocate for regime change in Iran — opposed a suggestion from Trump that he might support lifting some of the sanctions against Iran, according to The Washington Post. This disagreement was one of the reasons for Bolton’s ouster from the White House last week.
Monday, a spokesman for the Iranian Foreign Ministry said there was no possibility of a meeting between Rouhani and Trump at the General Assembly.

President’s foreign policy in shambles

Trump’s foreign policy agenda is now largely in shambles. The much-vaunted dealmaker has seen his negotiations with the North Koreans over their nuclear program fizzle and yield scant tangible results. Trump abruptly ended negotiations with the Taliban this month. Trump’s trade negotiations with the Chinese seem to be at an impasse and the possibility of an Israeli-Palestinian peace deal on his watch is close to zero.
Iran is turning up the heat against the Saudis as well as the United States following the re-imposition of US sanctions against the Iranians by the Trump administration last year. The new round of US sanctions has more than halved Iran’s oil exports, its key revenue source.
The Iranian Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and its elite Quds Forces and Iranian proxies around the Middle East are fighting back to signal their anger with the Trump-imposed sanctions.
The Trump administration has blamed Iran for Saturday’s attack against key Saudi oil facilities that disrupted around half the country’s oil capacity.
Ramping up the “maximum pressure” campaign on the Iranians has helped lead to Saturday’s serious attack on the Saudis, a close US ally, which has put global oil markets into a tailspin and simultaneously ramped up the possibility of a wider regional war. Art of the Deal, indeed.
The Iranians have denied responsibility for Saturday’s attack, which is their routine response when they or their proxies carry out attacks in the region.
President Trump tweeted Sunday that the United States is “locked and loaded depending on verification” of who was behind Saturday’s attack in Saudi Arabia.

The negotiated path

So what will happen between Trump and Iran? Negotiations are vastly preferable to a war. And that seems to be Trump’s natural inclination.
The President sent additional troops to Afghanistan only reluctantly in 2017 and was pursuing a withdrawal agreement with the Taliban until he abruptly canceled the negotiations earlier this month. At the end of 2018, he said he was going to pull all US troops out of Syria, precipitating the resignation of the secretary of defense, Jim Mattis. Trump has gone from threatening “fire and fury” on the North Koreans to declaring his “love” for Kim Jong Un.
Now Trump has only an acting national security adviser in place to coordinate the range of military and diplomatic courses of action he might choose from to retaliate against Iran at a time when he has his first genuine foreign policy crisis to deal with.
Does anyone know what Trump’s achievable end goals are with Iran, including the President himself?

How Bolton got himself fired, CNN. com

Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is completing a book about President Trump’s national security team and policies. The opinions expressed in this commentary are his own. View more opinion articles at CNN.

(CNN)John Bolton’s defenestration was a long time coming. On so many issues — North Korea, Iran, and Venezuela — President Trump’s national security adviser’s bellicose views and advice repeatedly clashed with those of his mercurial boss.

Bolton was a workaholic who would routinely rise at 3:30 a.m., and he understood on a deep level how to operate in the DC bureaucracy — after all, he had started working in Washington for the Reagan administration.
Bolton was inclined to bring a gun to any bureaucratic knife fight. As soon as he assumed office as the national security adviser, Bolton immediately fired Tom Bossert, Trump’s homeland security adviser, who reported directly to the President and was, at least theoretically, of equal stature to Bolton.
Bolton was also steeped in the arcana of arms control negotiations and weapons-of-mass-destruction issues and had served as the top official at the State Department working on arms control in the George W. Bush administration, resulting in Bolton’s longstanding skepticism toward Iran. In 2015, Bolton wrote in the New York Times that the US should bomb Iran because “Iran will not negotiate away its nuclear program,” which is exactly what Iran did that same year by negotiating the nuclear agreement with the Obama administration and other world powers.
It was hardly surprising, then, that with Bolton now in place as national security adviser, Trump announced on May 8, 2018, that he was pulling out of the Iran nuclear agreement. As Bolton stood off to one side behind him, Trump gave a press conference at the White House announcing the pullout, saying, “The fact is that this was a horrible one-sided deal that should never, ever have been made.”
But in recent months Trump had made a number of conciliatory gestures to Iran. Following the Iranians bringing down an American drone in the Persian Gulf in June, Trump had approved a strike against Iranian missile batteries and radars but then he abruptly called off the operation.
Trump then said he would speak to the Iranians with “no preconditions.” This went against everything that Bolton had stood for as he had long pushed for regime change in Iran.
Iran’s foreign minister Mohammad Zarif told reporters in New York on July 18, 2019, that in exchange for the lifting of UN sanctions, Iran would allow international inspectors greater latitude to inspect its nuclear program.
Zarif didn’t have a huge amount of juice with the mullahs who actually ran the show in Iran, but Iran’s hardline former President, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, certainly did. Around the same time that Zarif made his offer, Ahmadinejad told the New York Times, “Mr. Trump is a man of action. He is a businessman and therefore he is capable of calculating cost-benefits and making a decision. We say to him, let’s calculate the long-term cost-benefit of our two nations and not be shortsighted.”
Trump seemed to now be looking for an opening to the Iranians which Bolton would surely have been an impediment to.

North Korea

Two months before meeting with Trump in Singapore in June 2018, North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un had declared that he was suspending nuclear weapons and missile tests.
However, Bolton seemed intent on sabotaging any accommodation with the North Koreans. A month before he had started to work at the White House, Bolton had written a piece for the Wall Street Journal in which he laid out the purported legal arguments for a preemptive war against North Korea. This would be a redo of the invasion of Iraq in 2003, of which Bolton remained a vocal supporter.
Within weeks of taking up his position as national security adviser, Bolton said publicly that the administration was contemplating the “Libya model” for North Korea.
This referred to the Libyan dictator Moammar Gadhafi, who had agreed to abandon his weapons-of-mass-destruction program in the early 2000s in exchange for lifting the onerous sanctions that were then in place on his regime. A few years later, in 2011, US-backed rebels toppled Gadhafi’s regime. The rebels then hunted Gadhafi down and killed him in a ditch.
For Kim, the “Libya model” was code for regime change; Kim had no intention of ending up dead in a ditch. Keeping his nukes was key to Kim’s plan to remain in power indefinitely.
The North Korean first deputy prime minister, Kim Kye-Gwan, said of Bolton, “We do not hide our feeling of repugnance towards him.”
Sarah Sanders, then-White House press secretary, quickly distanced the Trump administration from the “Libya model,” saying, “I’m not aware that that’s a model that we’re using.”
In February, Trump met Kim again in Hanoi, the capital of Vietnam, but Trump pulled out of the meeting early when Kim didn’t offer much in the way of “denuclearization.” Three months after the failed talks in Hanoi, the North Koreans launched some short-range ballistic missiles.
At a press conference in Japan in late May 2019, Trump contradicted Bolton, who had just told reporters that those launches contravened UN Security Council resolutions. Trump said he wasn’t bothered by the launches.
When Trump met with Kim Jong Un for the third time at the Demilitarized Zone between North and South Korea to discuss North Korea’s nuclear program, along tagged Jared and Ivanka Kushner, and Fox News’ Tucker Carlson. Meanwhile, Bolton, who had spent much of his professional career focused on arms control issues, went on a previously scheduled trip to . . . Mongolia.
Earlier this year Bolton had also pushed for a coup in Venezuela against the socialist strongman president Nicolás Maduro. A coup attempt by the country’s opposition, which the US supported, fizzled. Trump blamed Bolton for the botched coup.
Get our weekly newsletter

Sign up for CNN Opinion’s new newsletter.

Join us on Twitter and Facebook

In May, Trump said that he actually moderated the bellicose Bolton: “I’m the one who tempers him, which is OK. I have John Bolton and I have people who are a little more dovish than him.”
Given the amount of turnover in his cabinet, Trump couldn’t get rid of Bolton immediately, but he started thinking about other candidates to be his national security adviser, according to a former senior Trump administration official I have spoken to.
According to this official, Trump has met in recent months with Fox News talking head Colonel Douglas Macgregor, a retired army officer with a doctorate. Unlike Bolton, Macgregor is an extreme skeptic about American military interventions in the greater Middle East, appearing on Fox to rail against the “globalist elite” on Capitol Hill and at the Pentagon and State Department that were purportedly pushing for the continuation of the Afghan War. Macgregor has also appeared on Fox strongly opposing any kind of conflict with Iran. Of course, just because Trump has talked to Macgregor, that doesn’t mean he will necessarily be offered the job.
Trump wrote on Twitter Tuesday that he would appoint a new national security adviser by next week. It will be his fourth in that role.