Maxwell School, Syracuse Univ., Syracuse NY

NSI IMPACT 2019, Chantilly, VA

Agenda-at-a-Glance (* = Invited )

<

Monday, April 15, 2019
8:00 – 8:45 Keynote Address:
Countering Evolving Threats to National Security
Charles (Chuck) Durant, Deputy Director for Counterintelligence, DOE
8:45 – 9:30 Terrorism and Security: Mapping the Risks in 2019
Peter Bergen, VP, Global Studies & Fellows, New America
9:30 – 10:30 Opening of Awareness Fair, Expo and Refreshment Break
10:30 – 11:30 The Changing Nature of Cyber Threats: What FSO’s Need to Know
* Christopher Krebs, Director, DHS Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Agency
11:30 – 12:30 DSS: Developing a Risk-Based Approach to Industrial Security
Daniel E. Payne, Director, Defense Security Service
12:30 – 1:45 Luncheon, Awareness Fair and Expo
2:00 – 3:15 Workshops
Track 1
Security Awareness: Keeping Your Program Relevant
and Engaging
Tom Brown, Director, Government Security, AECOM
Track 2
Successfully Navigating the Changing DISS and NISS
Dr. Chuck Barber, Defense Vetting Directorate, Director of the Enterprise Business Support Office; Heather Green, Defense Vetting Directorate, Director of the Vetting Risk Operations and Ryan Deloney, Asst. Dep. Dir., Ind. Sec. Field Ops., DSS
3:15 – 3:45 Refreshment/Networking Break, Awareness Fair, Expo
3:45 – 5:00 Workshops
Track 1
Creating an Effective Travel Security Program
Matthew Bradley, Reg. Security Dir. Americas, International SOS
Track 2
How to Comply with the DSS Risk Management Framework
Karl Hellmann, Asst. Dep. Dir., NISP Authorization Office, DSS
5:00 – 6:30 Champagne Reception
Tuesday, April 16, 2019
8:00 – 8:45 U.S. Secrets Under Siege from Nation State Hackers, Spies
Mark Kelton, Former Dep. Dir. , National Clandestine Service & CI, CIA
8:45 – 9:30 DoD Security Program Policy Update
Garry Reid, Director of Defense Intelligence (DoD Intel and Security)
9:30 – 9:50 Refreshment/Networking Break
9:50 – 10:50 Security Clearance Program Transition: What to Expect
Charles Phalen, Director, NBIB
Perry Russell-Hunter, Director, DOHA
Tricia Stokes, Dir., Defense Vetting Directorate, DSS
10:50 – 11:50 Insider Threat: Prevention, Detection, Mitigation and Deterrence
Dr. Michael Gelles, Managing Director, Deloitte Consulting
12:00 – 1:30 Host Networking Luncheon
1:30 – 2:45 Workshops
Track 1
CUI Compliance: How to Get it Right
Devin Casey, Program Analyst, ISOO
Track 2
Assessing Your Insider Threat Program
Daniel McGarvey, Sr. Principal Bus. Process Analyst
Alion Science & Technology
2:45 – 3:05 Refreshment/Networking Break
3:05 – 4:20 Workshops
Track 1
DSS Industrial Security Program lssues and Answers
Gus Greene, Director, Industrial Security Field Operations, DSS
Track 2
Preparing for an Active Shooter Emergency in the Workplace
Capt. Douglas Watson, Winchester Police Dept., SWAT Team Commander
Wednesday, April 17, 2019
8:00 – 8:45 Chinese Espionage: Growing Risks to U.S. Defense Companies
FBI Counterintelligence Division
8:45 – 9:30

Low-Tech Threats: Protecting the People Side of Security

Ryan Kalember, Sr. VP of Cybersecurity Strategy, Proofpoint, Inc.
9:30 – 9:50 Refreshment/Networking Break
9:50 – 10:35 Annual State of the NISP
Mark A. Bradley, Director, Information Security Oversight Office
10:35 – 11:35 Showing How Security is a Value Add to Your Organization
Mitchell Lawrence, National Security Training Institute
CEO, Lawrence Solutions
11:35 – 11:45 Closing Remarks

Why we still need to worry about ISIS, CNN.com

Why we still need to worry about ISIS

Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is the author of “United States of Jihad: Investigating America’s Homegrown Terrorists.” View more opinion articles at CNN.

(CNN)ISIS has suffered a momentous blow with the defeat of its last physical stronghold, according to an announcement Saturday by the US-backed Syrian Democratic Forces.

SDF: ISIS loses final territory in Syria
At the height of its power four years ago, ISIS controlled an area in Iraq and Syria that was the size of Portugal and lorded over almost 8 million people — a population larger than that of Bulgaria. ISIS also ran a quasi-state that taxed and extorted its millions of subjects, enabling it to field a terrorist army with a large war chest.
While ISIS once attracted an estimated 40,000 people around the world to join its so-called caliphate, that number has since plummeted, as it seems no one wants to join the losing team.
While Trump, who took a premature victory lap last month, certainly contributed to ISIS’ demise, the conditions are still ripe for similarly dangerous terrorist groups to form and multiply.

What credit should be given to Trump?

The Trump administration did make a substantial shift in the fight against ISIS in Syria by arming Kurdish forces and increasing the US military presence there.
But it was the Obama administration that initiated the operation in 2016 to take back Mosul, the second largest city in Iraq, where ISIS first declared its “caliphate.” Under Obama, ISIS also lost key Iraqi cities including Fallujah, Ramadi and Tikrit.
The Obama administration, however, was so concerned about “mission creep” in Syria that it capped the number of US troops there to 500.
In the waning months of Obama’s second term, his Cabinet debated whether to arm Syrian Kurds, who would be key to taking back cities like Raqqa — which served as ISIS’s headquarters. But the US would risk angering Turkey, which considers the Syrian Kurds to be closely aligned with a terrorist group in Turkey.
The Obama team debated this option for so long that it eventually ran out of time to implement it. When it finally approached the incoming administration with the plan to do so, former national security adviser Michael Flynn reportedly rejected it on the grounds that the Trump team wanted to conduct its own assessment of the situation.
After Trump entered office, he approved a plan to arm the Kurdish forces in Syria and dramatically increased the number of US troops there from 500 to 2,000. He also gave his ground commanders greater authority to take military action against ISIS without consulting with the White House.
Days before Raqqa was liberated from ISIS in October 2017, President Donald Trump lauded himself in an interview and said, “I totally changed rules of engagement. I totally changed our military, I totally changed the attitudes of the military….” He also claimed ISIS hadn’t been defeated earlier because “you didn’t have Trump as your president.”
What happens to ISIS now?
Trump can certainly take credit for hastening the demise of ISIS, but ultimately, the US’ strategy was remarkably similar under both presidents. Instead of relying heavily on large numbers of US troops, both presidents used US Special Forces to train and advise local forces. The ground fight against ISIS was almost entirely conducted by Iraqi and Syrian soldiers.
Trump tends to define any course of action that he takes as being markedly different from Obama, but in the case of the anti-ISIS campaign, there were more similarities than differences between the two presidents.

Will ISIS live on?

ISIS has lost its physical territory in Iraq and Syria, and is significantly weaker without a base from which it can train thousands of militants. But it is likely to continue to inspire attacks around the world as a virtual caliphate.
And the real problem is that the conditions in the Middle East that gave rise to ISIS still exist and are likely to produce similar jihadist groups. Those problems include deep sectarianism, fragile or failed governments, and weak economies. Throw in the fast-growing population of the Middle East, and you have a toxic mix that will continue to produce the kind of anger upon which groups such as ISIS feed.
We should be ready for an offshoot of ISIS to form in places like Afghanistan, Libya, Yemen, or any other weak state in the region. It may not grow to be as powerful or widespread as ISIS, but the truth remains that there will be a successor group.
It would be dangerous for Trump to celebrate the fall of ISIS without keeping this in mind. To do so would be to commit the same mistake that President Obama made in January 2014, when he dismissed the group that would soon morph into ISIS as a “junior varsity” team.

Why terrorists kill: The striking similarities between the New Zealand and Pulse nightclub shooters, CNN.com

Publication Logo
CNN.com

March 18, 2019 Monday 1:29 PM EST

Why terrorists kill: The striking similarities between the New Zealand and Pulse nightclub shooters

BYLINE: By Peter Bergen, CNN National Security Analyst

SECTION: OPINIONS

LENGTH: 1183 words

The decision to kill innocent civilians who are strangers — whether you are a jihadist terrorist or a white nationalist militant — can never be easily explained, but there does seem to be a common profile for “lone actor” Western terrorists today, irrespective of their ideology.

First, they are radicalizing because of what they read online. ISIS created a vast global library of propaganda that influenced terrorists such as Omar Mateen, who killed 49 people in the Pulse nightclub in Orlando, Florida, in June 2016. Mateen never met with anyone in ISIS and never traveled to Iraq or Syria where ISIS was headquartered. His radicalization was entirely driven by what he viewed on the internet.

Similarly, Brenton Tarrant, the terrorist who allegedly carried out the New Zealand attacks, killing 50 people, tapped into a large library of white nationalist material from around the world on the internet, according to the document that Tarrant posted about his motivations for the attacks.

Tarrant’s heroes were right-wing terrorists from around the West: Darren Osborne. who killed a Muslim man near a mosque in North London two years ago; Dylann Roof. who killed nine African-Americans in a church in South Carolina in 2015, and, above all, Norwegian neo-Nazi Anders Breivik, who killed 77 people in 2011.

Just as school shooters in the United States model themselves and learn from other school shooters, so too do aspiring terrorists learn from and emulate other terrorists.

Nothing in Tarrant’s manifesto suggests that he was indoctrinated in-person or was trained by a white nationalist group. Like Mateen, he radicalized because of what he saw online.

Second, both Mateen and Tarrant seem to have been drifting through life while they shopped for an ideology that justified acts of violence.

Mateen flirted first with the Shia militant group Hezbollah and then with the Sunni militant group al Qaeda, according to co-workers, before he finally settled on the ultra-violent Sunni group, ISIS.

According to his manifesto, Tarrant embraced anarchism, communism and libertarianism before finally settling on white nationalism.

Mateen nurtured dreams of becoming a policeman but instead was working as a security guard at a golf community, which was not his heroic self-conception of his proper role in life.

As he carried out the attack on June 12, 2016, Mateen told a 911 operator, “My name is ‘I pledge allegiance to Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi.” Baghdadi is the self-styled caliph of ISIS, which quickly claimed Mateen as a “soldier of the caliphate.” Mateen was no longer a security guard at a golf community, now, in his own eyes and those of ISIS, he was a real soldier.

Similarly, according to Tarrant’s account in his manifesto, he was going nowhere fast in life. Tarrant “did not attend university” because he “had no great interest in anything offered in the universities to study.” Instead, Tarrant, an Australian, was drifting around the world as a tourist in France, Spain and Portugal and eventually New Zealand.

Just as Mateen was a “soldier” for ISIS and pledged his allegiance to the caliph, Tarrant said in his manifesto that before he carried out his attacks he contacted the “reborn Knights Templar for a blessing…” The Knights Templar were crusaders against Muslim rule in the Middle East during the Middle Ages. Tarrant’s hero, Breivik, claimed they had reconstituted in the 21st century.

In both cases, the terrorists were no longer merely zeros, they were now heroes in their own minds, acting either as a soldier of the caliphate or with the blessing of the Knights Templar.

Third, just as the adherents of other murderous ideologies that preceded them believed, Mateen and Tarrant felt that utopia here on earth could only be achieved by the removal of “the Other.” For Stalinists it was the kulaks. For the Nazis it was, of course, the Jews. For ISIS, it is the Shia and other “infidels.” For violent white nationalists it is non-whites, and particularly immigrants.

As we saw with the globalization of ISIS’ ideology, which led to outbreaks of terrorism across the West, the increasing prevalence of white nationalist ideas around the globe has provided fertile ground for acts of violence.

Political leaders in several Western countries feel no compunction about staking their careers on white nationalist themes that are typically anti-immigrant, often anti-Muslim and sometimes anti-Semitic.

A few years ago these ideas were on the fringes of politics in the West, but they have now entered the mainstream.

Consider that Viktor Orban, the Hungarian prime minister, has built his political career on anti-immigrant stances. Orban has also made a central part of his platform the denigration of the Jewish American-Hungarian billionaire, George Soros, as a “puppet master.” A common anti-Semitic slur is that Jews are the secret puppet masters controlling the world.

Poland’s ruling nationalist Law and Justice Party is led by Jaroslaw Kaczynski, who has variously said that immigrants carry “all sorts of parasites and protozoa,” that they have imposed sharia law in parts of Sweden and that they use churches in Italy as “toilets.”

Geert Wilders was once a marginal figure in Dutch politics but in 2017, his party came in second in parliamentary elections.

Wilders has long espoused a wide variety of anti-Islamic views.

Similarly, Marine Le Pen in France was also once at the margins of French politics. In 2010, Le Pen compared Muslims praying on the street to the Nazi occupation of France. Seven years later, Le Pen lost the French presidential election to Emmanuel Macron, but she still garnered a third of the votes.

In 2017, the anti-Muslim party Alternative for Germany (AfD) became the third largest party in the German parliament even though it was only founded four years earlier.

President Donald Trump’s views about Mexican immigrants are, of course, well known, as was his campaign promise to ban Muslims from entering the United States. On Friday, Trump referred to immigrants on the US’ southern border as part of an “invasion.”

Similarly, Tarrant described Muslim immigrants in his manifesto as “invaders.”

The man who killed 11 people at a Pittsburgh synagogue last October repeatedly referred to immigrants from Mexico and Central America as “invaders” and blamed a Jewish organization that helps refugees.

Of course, merely espousing white nationalist views doesn’t make you a terrorist any more than merely espousing views about jihadism make you a terrorist. But these ideas are a necessary feature of acts of white nationalist terrorism of the kind that took place in Christchurch, New Zealand, on Friday, or for the acts of jihadist terrorism that have plagued the West for many years.

Both Mateen and Tarrant needed the ideologies of ISIS and white nationalism to give them the justification to murder dozens of innocent strangers. Both radicalized online and felt that they were carrying out heroic missions that would help set the conditions for some utopian future. Of course, all they achieved was to create a hell here on earth for their victims and their families.

 

The Terrorist Threat to Multinational Corporations: Challenges and Opportunities, New America DC

The Terrorist Threat to Multinational Corporations: Challenges and Opportunities

Event

Multinational corporations have long been a target of terrorism, yet the threat has also changed as multinational corporations increase their reach, terrorism and resilient insurgencies diffuse across multiple regions, and new technologies change the potential for attacks. What are the main terrorist threats to multinational corporations today, and what methods are in use to provide security?

To discuss these issues New America’s International Security Program welcomes Dr. Richard J. Chasdi, a Professorial Lecturer in the Department of Political Science at The George Washington University and an Adjunct Senior Fellow at the International Centre for Political Violence and Terrorism Research at Nanyang Technological University. Dr. Chasdi holds a Ph.D. in political science from Purdue University, and is the author of four books on terrorism studies and counterterrorism.

Participant:

Richard J. Chasdi
Adjunct Senior Fellow, International Centre for Political Violence and Terrorism Research
Professional Lecturer, George Washington University

Moderator:

Peter Bergen, @perterbergencnn
Vice President, New America

Follow the conversation online using #MNCThreat and following NewAmericaISP.

“Long Game or Long Gone? Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and the State of U.S. Counterterrorism.” CSIS, DC

DC Daybook – Policy & News Events

March 26, 2019 Tuesday 02:00 PM GMT

The Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) – Discussion

SECTION: WAGEN; Foreign Affairs

LENGTH: 106 words

STATUS: New

TIME: 14:00

EVENT: The Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) holds a discussion on “Long Game or Long Gone? Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and the State of U.S. Counterterrorism.”

PARTICIPANTS: Peter Bergen, vice president for global studies at New America; Bruce Hoffman, senior fellow for counterterrorism and homeland security at the Council on Foreign Relations; and Seth Jones, director of the CSIS Transnational Threats Project

DATE: March 26, 2019

LOCATION: CSIS, 1616 Rhode Island Avenue NW, Washington, D.C.

 

Trump’s Taliban Negotiations: What it Means for Afghanistan, New America DC

Trump’s Taliban Negotiations: What it Means for Afghanistan

On February 25th, the United States and the Taliban are scheduled to hold the next round of peace talks aimed at ending the now 17-year-old conflict, America’s longest war. Yet, the negotiations are occurring in a period of Taliban strength and with the Afghan government expressing concern that they are being left out of the dealmaking process. What are the prospects for the U.S.-Taliban negotiations, and what do they mean for Afghanistan and the current Afghan government?

To discuss these issues New America’s International Security Program welcomes Ioannis Koskinas, a senior fellow with New America’s International Security Program who has been based in Afghanistan for the past seven years, and Peter Bergen, Vice President of New America. The discussion will be moderated by Awista Ayub, Director of New America’s Fellows program, author of Kabul Girls Soccer Club, and previously Director of South Asia Programs at Seeds of Peace.

Participants:

Ioannis Koskinas
Senior Fellow, New America’s International Security Program
CEO, Hoplite Group

Peter Bergen
Vice President, New America
Co-Editor, Talibanistan

Moderator:

Awista Ayub
Director, New America’s Fellows Program
Author, Kabul Girls Soccer Club

Coast Guard officer’s alleged massacre plot is terrifying echo of our politics, CNN.com

Coast Guard officer’s alleged massacre plot is terrifying echo of our politics

coast guard lieutenant terror plot hit list schneider tsr vpx_00041724

Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is the author of “United States of Jihad: Investigating America’s Homegrown Terrorists.” The opinions expressed in this commentary are his own. View more opinion articles at CNN.

(CNN)Coast Guard Lt. Christopher Paul Hasson of Silver Spring, Maryland, was arrested nearly a week ago on weapons and drug charges by authorities who said he was planning to commit mass murder. They said Hasson had a hit list, which included Democratic politicians and anchors at CNN and MSNBC.

Hasson had assembled a small arsenal of 15 firearms and more than 1,000 rounds of ammunition, according to a court filing by federal prosecutors.
A month before his arrest, Hasson performed Google searches such as “what if trump illegally impeached,” the court documents say.
Hasson was influenced by Anders Breivik, a neo-Nazi who killed 77 people in Norway in 2011, according to the court filing. Breivik had written a manifesto about the necessity of targeting political and media leaders. Hasson made a list of prominent media personalities he seemed to be planning to target, including Don Lemon and Chris Cuomo of CNN and Joe Scarborough and Chris Hayes of MSNBC, authorities said.
The Hasson case is the latest reminder of the risks posed by lone terrorists, whose anger can be directed at journalists and politicians. Often, such terrorists have unresolved grievances in their lives and then find an ideology that allows them to commit violence, according to J. Reid Meloy, a forensic psychologist who researches lone terrorists.
Those terrorists can be inspired by any number of things, but inflated political rhetoric is a potential contributing factor.
Take the case of Robert Bowers, who is accused of killing 11 Jews at a Pittsburgh synagogue in October. Bowers appears to have been inspired by rhetoric about migrant caravans in Mexico heading toward the United States being “invaders.” Bowers repeatedly called them “invaders” when he posted to the website, Gab, and blamed Jewish organizations for purportedly enabling these migrants.
In a similar vein, Hasson wrote — in a draft email from 2017 found in his deleted file, authorities said — that “Liberalist/globalist ideology is destroying traditional peoples esp white. No way to counteract without violence.”‘
Hasson’s case may suggest that President Donald Trump’s repeatedly calling the media “the enemy of the people” can have consequences.
Earlier this month, a Trump supporter at a rally in El Paso, Texas, attacked a BBC cameraman. Trump routinely denounces the media covering his rallies.
And in October explosive devices were mailed to leaders of the Democratic Party and to CNN. Cesar Sayoc, a Trump supporter and DJ living out of his van in Florida, was identified as the suspect in the case.
Most presidents haven’t loved their press converge, but Trump’s demonization of the media simply doing their jobs is at another level of magnitude than previous US leaders.
The architect of the raid that killed Osama bin Laden, retired Adm. William McRaven, had it right when he said that “the President’s attack on the media is the greatest threat to our democracy in my lifetime. When you undermine the people’s right to a free press and freedom of speech and expression, then you threaten the Constitution and all for which it stands.”
Trump’s latest “enemy of the people” is The New York Times for an article it published this week about Trump’s attempts to influence investigations into, among other things, payoffs to women who claim to have had sex with him.
Trump resorts to the slogan “fake news” and the Stalinist appellation “enemy of the people” when he doesn’t like the stories that are written about him. Yet he rarely engages on the substance of these stories. Rather he tries to create a miasma of doubt around what the proper role of the press is.
Trump’s verbal assaults on the media are just one more example of his assaults on the institutions of American life, such as the FBI and the Department of Justice.
This will all come to a head in the coming weeks as special counsel Robert Mueller prepares to deliver his final report on the investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election. Despite the likely efforts of the Trump administration to bury the report, since we live in an open society, it will likely eventually leak.
Should that happen, the press should be prepared for a Vesuvian eruption from Trump about how the media are the enemy of the people, intent on promoting fake news.

St. John’s Church, Lafayette Square, Washington DC

New-Website-Header.jpg

Afghans fear Trump team is about to sell them out, CNN.com

Afghans fear Trump team is about to sell them out

Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and professor of practice at Arizona State University. He has reported from Afghanistan for two and a half decades and is the co-editor of “Talibanistan: Negotiating the Borders Between Terror, Politics, and Religion.” The opinions expressed in this commentary are his own; view more opinion at CNN.

Kabul, Afghanistan (CNN) Kabul is a city on edge. Twenty-foot-high concrete blast walls surround the “Green Zone,” sheltering the US embassy and key Afghan government buildings.

It is the one of the largest American embassies in the world, yet the US officials working there rarely leave the Green Zone, and if they do, it is by helicopter.
By contrast, in December the Iraqi government began taking down the walls around the Green Zone in Baghdad because the security situation has markedly improved there.
Several years ago, westerners could live and work in Kabul with little cause for fear, and there was even a bustling restaurant scene. That sense of security has gone now because of the Taliban campaign of bombings in the capital and their targeted kidnappings of foreigners. That has helped to contribute to a sharp drop in foreign direct investment in Afghanistan in recent years, according to World Bank data.
The Taliban are at their strongest since their regime fell in the months after the 9/11 attacks. According to a US government assessment released last month, the Afghan government controls around two-thirds of the population and the Taliban 10%. The rest of the population is contested between the government and the Taliban.
ISIS and al Qaeda both now have footholds in Afghanistan.
That is the backdrop for the American talks with the Taliban which began in earnest in July.
These talks are directly between the US and the Taliban, long a key demand of the Taliban. They revile the Afghan government as a puppet of the United States and have called for the removal of all American troops. There are presently some 14,000 US military personnel in the country.
Seven months after the talks began between the US and the Taliban, the Afghan government remains excluded from them despite the fact that their outcome could deeply affect the Afghan people that it represents.
So, Afghans are asking: Are the US-Taliban talks a prelude to peace, or a betrayal of a US ally in which the terms of their surrender to the Taliban are being discussed without them?
The veteran American diplomat, Ryan Crocker, certainly thinks it’s the latter. Under the self-explanatory headline, “I was ambassador to Afghanistan. This deal is a surrender,” Crocker, in the Washington Post, compared the negotiations with the Taliban “to the Paris peace talks during the Vietnam War. Then, as now, it was clear that by going to the table we were surrendering; we were just negotiating the terms of our surrender.”
The Paris peace deal was followed by the eventual collapse of the South Vietnamese government, which had been America’s ally, and to the unification of the country under North Vietnam’s communist leader, Ho Chi Minh.

Crisis of confidence

Discussion of a withdrawal of US troops has created a crisis of confidence among the many Afghans who have benefitted from the post-Taliban era. The beneficiaries of that era, now in its 18th year, include women and ethnic minorities such as the Hazaras as well as the new millennial generation of urban Afghans who were children when the Taliban were in power and have no nostalgia for an era when the country was taken back to the Middle Ages.
A senior Afghan female official described the US-Taliban talks to me as a “betrayal.”
A common refrain that I also heard from Afghans: Why was the US bothering with the pretense of negotiating with the Taliban if it was all along intent on heading for the exits? “If you are gonna leave, just leave. We will have to fight when you are gone anyway,” they said.
Then there is the demonstration effect. As they try and set the terms for an American withdrawal from Afghanistan, the Taliban can now claim that they have defeated two superpowers, first the Soviets and now the Americans, a claim that is sure to inspire jihadist groups around the world.
Already the purported American “defeat” in Afghanistan has inspired the suicide bomber who killed 37 Indian soldiers in Indian-held Kashmir on Thursday, the most lethal attack in Kashmir for many years. Before the operation the bomber recorded a “martyrdom” video in which he said he was inspired to carry out the attack by the news of the American withdrawal from Afghanistan.

The dealmaker

Zalmay Khalilzad, Trump’s Special Representative for Afghanistan, is leading the talks on the American side. Following a marathon six-days of discussions between American diplomats and the Taliban in the Qatari capital, Doha, in late January Khalilzad tweeted, “Meetings here were more productive than they have been in the past. We made significant progress on vital issues.”
That tweet precipitated a flurry of new stories about a potential peace deal.
Khalilzad also tweeted that he had briefed Afghan President Ashraf Ghani “on the progress we have made.”
President Ghani and Khalilzad have a five-decade relationship that stretches back to when they were both classmates at the American University in Beirut. They have quite different styles, crystallized in the books they each have written.
Ghani co-wrote “Fixing Failed States” with development expert Clare Lockhart, a technocratic account of how to fix countries such as Afghanistan, while Khalilzad wrote “The Envoy,” an account of his many years as a diplomat working at the highest levels of the US government. If Ghani is the workaholic technocrat, Khalilzad is the wheeler dealer looking to work out an arrangement.
While it’s not known whether Khalilzad has spoken to President Trump directly about his negotiations with the Taliban, his boss is Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and they both seem to be trying to fulfill a campaign promise by Trump that the United States should extricate itself from its expensive foreign wars.
A similar impetus can be seen behind the precipitous drawdown of US troops in Syria, which CENTCOM Commander General Joseph Votel told CNN’s Barbara Starr on Friday he would have advised against given the fact that ISIS is not defeated.

The deal

The “framework” for a possible peace agreement that Khalilzad has negotiated is that the Taliban have agreed that they will not allow Afghanistan to be used as a launching pad for attacks by international terrorist groups such as al Qaeda.
This is a demand that the United States has made for the past two decades since al Qaeda bombed two US embassies in Africa in August 1998, killing more than two hundred people, attacks that the group carried out when it was based in Afghanistan. The Taliban continued to shelter Osama bin Laden after those bombings and even as he was planning the far more lethal 9/11 attacks. After 9/11, the Taliban then refused to hand bin Laden over to the United States and the war began.
In return for the Taliban pledge that they will no longer provide a safe haven to international terrorist groups, US forces would withdraw from Afghanistan, ending America’s longest war.
Also, there are discussions between the Taliban and US officials of a possible ceasefire, as well as of direct negotiations between the Afghan government and the Taliban, though the Taliban reportedly has not agreed to either of these so far.
Khalilzad has said publicly that he hopes the negotiations will wind up before the key Afghan presidential election five months from now.
This seems a tad optimistic since peace negotiations to end a civil war typically take many years. The British negotiated with the IRA for two decades before there was a peace deal in Northern Ireland.

Uncompromising Taliban

But the bigger issue is that the Taliban are seemingly in no mood for any kind of real compromise. The lead Taliban negotiator, Sher Mohammad Abbas Stanekzai, said in an interview with a Pashtu language website earlier this month that the Taliban will not negotiate with the Afghan government until the full withdrawal of foreign forces, including all troops, advisors and contractors.
Stanekzai also said that the Taliban plans to abolish the Afghan army and that the Afghan constitution will be amended and based on their version of Sharia law.
In other words, following the withdrawal of all US forces, the Taliban wants the Afghan government to unilaterally disarm and they will then write a new constitution they regard as sufficiently Islamic.
The Afghan constitution ratified in 2004 guarantees the rights of women to work and girls to be educated. Given the Taliban’s dismal track record about the rights of women and girls, it’s hard to believe that these rights wouldn’t be curtailed or even abolished in a future Taliban utopia.
Adding to the anxiety that many Afghans have was the meeting in Moscow on February 5 between the Taliban and leading Afghan politicians such as former Afghan President Hamid Karzai. Again, the Afghan government played no role in those discussions.
One of the Afghan delegates at the Moscow meeting told me that the mood of the Taliban there was “victorious.”
Nothing of course would give the former KGB officer, Russian President Vladimir Putin, greater satisfaction than handing the United States a bloody nose in Afghanistan just as the US-backed Afghan guerillas did to the Soviets in Afghanistan during the 1980s.

What can be done?

The Afghan government has had no success at getting a seat at the table during the past seven months of negotiations between the US and the Taliban. In order to wrest back some control of the initiative President Ghani last week called for a consultative loya jirga, a traditional Afghan tribal council, to discuss the talks with the Taliban.
This seems to be an attempt to show that Afghans want to decide their own fate rather than have it negotiated over their heads between the Taliban and the United States.
Ghani has also offered in a private letter to Trump to cut costs for the US military in Afghanistan.
Gianni Koskinas, a former Special Operations Air Force colonel and New America senior fellow who deployed extensively in Afghanistan while in uniform and who has lived in Kabul since 2011, says there are also plenty of savings that could be made by reducing the size of the American “footprint” in Afghanistan. Every American soldier is estimated to cost more than a million dollars a year when deployed in Afghanistan.
With only a small fraction of the 14,000 American troops ever operating outside their bases, Koskinas estimates that 8,000 troops would be more than enough to sustain counterterrorism operations and the crucial US “advise and assist” mission to key components of the Afghan National Security Forces such as the Air Force and Special Forces. Koskinas argues that the drawdown should focus mostly on American conventional forces that deliver little in the current environment in Afghanistan.
Also “winning” the war in Afghanistan is simply the wrong frame to be looking at the issue. The United States is there to manage and contain the threat from international terrorist groups based in the region. This doesn’t require a large force.
As the military historian and CNN contributor Max Boot has pointed out, the annual toll taken by US military training accidents is now four times larger than American combat losses in Afghanistan.
What it does require is a long-term commitment to Afghanistan of the kind that President Trump promised when he announced his new Afghanistan strategy in a speech on August 21, 2017, at Fort Meyer in Virginia. Wouldn’t it be nice if he kept that promise?