Trump’s laughable southern border scare
By Peter Bergen, CNN National Security Analyst
“Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University.”
(CNN)The caravan of some 7,500 migrants wending its way north through Mexico is a political gift to President Donald Trump, who ran successfully on a get-tough on immigration and terrorism platform during his presidential campaign.
Trump tweeted Monday that there are “unknown Middle Easterners mixed” in with the thousands of migrants. The intent of this tweet is surely to play on American fears about the possibility of mysterious Middle Easterners attacking the country, as they did on 9/11.
There is just one problem with this notion: Every lethal terrorist attack in the United States since 9/11 has been carried out by a US citizen or legal resident, according to New America, a research institution that tracks jihadist terrorism cases.
In addition, of the more than 400 jihadist terrorist cases prosecuted in the United States in the past 17 years, not one of the terrorists infiltrated the country across the southern border, according to New America’s research.
Of course, the notion of a terrorist joining a caravan of migrants who are being filmed continuously for a matter of weeks is implausible on its face.
Since 9/11, three foreign terrorist organizations have mounted serious plots to attack the United States, and all the plotters flew into the country from South Asia and the Middle East. None of them crossed over the US-Mexico border.
Najibullah Zazi was trained by al Qaeda to blow up bombs in the Manhattan subway in 2009. He arrived in the United States from Pakistan by plane.
So too did Faisal Shahzad, whom the Pakistani Taliban trained to blow up a bomb in Manhattan a year later. Neither plot succeeded.
“Underwear bomber” Umar Farouk AbdulMutallab flew into the country on Christmas Day 2009 on the plane that he tried unsuccessfully to blow up over Detroit. Al Qaeda in Yemen had trained him.
The only cross-border infiltration by a terrorist was almost two decades ago when Ahmed Ressam, an Algerian, was arrested on a ferry arriving in Washington state from Canada on December 14, 1999. As Ressam’s car rolled out of the ferry, a US customs inspector pulled him over. Agents found 130 pounds of explosives in Ressam’s car. Ressam planned to bomb Los Angeles International Airport.
Despite the Ressam case, fomenting fears of terrorists crossing the border from Canada hasn’t gained much political traction in the United States.
The view that terrorists are streaming across the southern border, however, is not uncommon among Trump supporters, not least retired Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn, who was Tr
ump’s first national security adviser and who claimed in an August 2016 interview that there were Arabic signs along the US-Mexico border to guide potential terrorists into the States.
Flynn said, “I have personally seen the photos of the signage along those paths that are in Arabic. They’re like waypoints along that path as you come in. Primarily, in this case the one that I saw was in Texas and it’s literally, it’s like signs, that say, in Arabic, ‘This way, move to this point.’ It’s unbelievable.”
It was unbelievable, of course, because it was totally false.
So too is the canard that Mexico is a hotbed of jihadist terrorism, but that is not going to get in the way of Trump trying to make this an issue as the midterm elections draw closer.
Yes, there is such a thing as right-wing terrorism
By Peter Bergen, CNN National Security Analyst
Updated 9:49 AM ET, Fri October 26, 2018
“Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University.”
(CNN)A common trope on the right is that the suspected bombs sent to Democratic Party leaders, CNN and critics of President Donald Trump couldn’t have been sent by a right-wing terrorist.
On his radio show, Rush Limbaugh asserted, “Republicans just don’t do this kind of thing.”
Prominent conservative commentator Ann Coulter tweeted to her more than 2 million followers, “From the Haymarket riot to the Unibomber (sic) bombs are a liberal tactic.”
Fox Business News anchor Lou Dobbs — in a since-deleted tweet — claimed that the devices were “Fake news-Fake bombs. Who could possibly benefit by so much fakery?”
Of course, we don’t yet know the exact motivation of the person responsible for the mail bombs, but we do know that there is, in fact, a long history of political violence emanating from the far right. Claims that bombings are a liberal tactic, or that right-wing terrorists don’t exist, are simply false.
Recall first that the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing was, at the time, the most lethal act of terrorism ever on US soil. The bombing killed 168 people and was carried out by Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols, who both had a long association with far-right causes.
Indeed, since 9/11, terrorists motivated by far-right ideologies have killed 73 people in the United States, according to New America, a research institution that tracks political violence.
Meanwhile, during the same time period in the United States, eight people were killed by terrorists motivated by black nationalist ideology, while jihadist terrorists have killed 104.
Leftist terrorists have not killed anyone during this period in the United States, though an anti-Trump fanatic shot and gravely wounded Rep. Steve Scalise of Louisiana, senior House Republican, last year in Virginia when he was attending a baseball practice.
We simply don’t know yet who is responsible for this series of pipe bomb packages or why they sent them, but those asserting that it couldn’t be a right-wing terrorist clearly have no knowledge about the history of terrorism in the United States.
Homegrown terrorism: A plague we cannot ignore
By Peter Bergen, CNN National Security Analyst
Updated 12:20 PM ET, Sun October 28, 2018
“Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is the author of “United States of Jihad: Investigating America’s Homegrown Terrorists.”
(CNN)9/11 is one of the hinge events in American history. Understandably Americans therefore tend to filter the concept of “terrorism” though the lens of jihadist terrorism.
Saturday’s massacre at a Jewish synagogue in Pittsburgh reminds us that political violence, partly enabled by the most permissive gun laws in the West, is a recurring plague in the United States.
If the series of bombs mailed this past week to multiple leaders of the Democratic Party, CNN and to prominent Jewish philanthropist George Soros was not reminder enough, now we have the tragedy in Pittsburgh that reminds us that lethal anti-Semitism is a feature of American domestic terrorism. According to a statement from the Anti-Defamation League, the killings were “the deadliest attack on the Jewish community in the history of the United States.”
Grim toll
Since 9/11, 18 people have been killed in anti-Semitic attacks in the United States.
In 2002, Egyptian-American Hesham Mohamed Hadayet shot up the ticket counter of the Israeli airline El Al at Los Angeles International Airport, killing two people before an airline security guard shot him dead.
The same year, Pakistani-American Naveed Haq killed a woman at a Jewish community center in the Seattle area and wounded five others.
In 2009, James W. von Brunn, a white supremacist, killed a security guard at the US Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington DC.
Five years later, Frazier Glenn Cross, shouted “Heil Hitler” after killing three people — two at the Jewish Community Center in Kansas City and one at a Jewish retirement community nearby.
Now comes Saturday’s massacre near Pittsburgh in which at least 11 people were killed by Robert Bowers, who made anti-Semitic statements during the shooting, according to law enforcement officials who spoke to CNN.
Bowers blamed Jews for the migrant caravan that is now moving through Mexico, according to his social media posts.
A week of terrorism
In the wake of the wave of multiple suspected bombs that were mailed to Democratic party leaders, CNN and Soros, prominent Trump supporters such as Lou Dobbs, Anne Coulter and Rush Limbaugh all made comments which essentially disputed the notion that such a terrorist incident could have come from the right.
They were immediately proved wrong Friday with the arrest of a Florida man, who plastered his van with stickers backing Donald Trump and assailing Democrats.
And that narrative was emphatically put to rest with the tragic attack on Saturday.
This past week, racist violence in the United States claimed the lives of two African-Americans in a Kroger store in the Louisville area on Wednesday by alleged shooter Gregory A. Bush Sr., 51.
Bush, who is white, had a history of making racist threats and he had tried unsuccessfully to gain entry to a predominantly black church just minutes before the Kroger shooting, according to local police.
The terrorist attacks in Pittsburgh and Louisville bring the total number of deaths perpetrated by far-right extremists in the United States since 9/11 to 86 people, according to New America, a research institution that tracks political violence. Meanwhile, jihadist terrorists have killed 104 during the same time period, according to the same research.
Taking the threat seriously
After 9/11, America went on a war footing and instituted a huge number of expensive measures to protect the homeland from the jihadist threat. But now that we see the horrors of domestic terrorism play out, are there things which should be done to take this threat more seriously?
A spokesman for the FBI Agents Association told CNN’s Josh Campbell on Saturday, “It is time to treat domestic terrorism as the national threat that it is, and track, analyze and punish political violence at the federal level. Winning the fight against domestic terrorism is not about parties or political views; it is about ending political violence.” The spokesman observed that domestic terrorism is not currently a federal crime.
Making domestic terrorism a federal crime would certainly make a powerful statement that all forms of political violence are unacceptable.
A complicating factor in the United States is that the First Amendment protects all hateful speech. This is not the case in countries such as the United Kingdom, where inciting racial or religious hatred is a crime, or in Germany, where Holocaust denial is a crime.
While it is a crime for an American to provide support to a State Department-designated Foreign Terrorist Organization such as ISIS, the First Amendment allows Americans to support or be part of neo-Nazi organizations as well as leftist militant movements.
If there were to be federal statute that allowed Americans to be charged for domestic terrorism, it would have to be artfully constructed so that it doesn’t end up criminalizing protected speech, only violent conduct.
Publication Logo
CNN.com
October 30, 2018 Tuesday 4:42 PM EST
Zeros trying to be heroes: what motivates terrorists
BYLINE: By Peter Bergen, CNN National Security Analyst
SECTION: OPINIONS
LENGTH: 924 words
When I was researching a book about Americans becoming violent jihadists, again and again I was struck by how often they were men who were going nowhere fast in life and who turned to violent jihadist ideology as a way of giving their lives greater meaning. They were often zeros trying to be heroes in their own story.
The terrorist incidents of the past week in the United States show that this can also be the case for alleged right-wing terrorists such as Cesar Sayoc, who is accused of mailing crude bombs to prominent Democrats and others, and Robert Bowers, who is accused of killing 11 at a synagogue in Pittsburgh.
Both Sayoc and Bowers display some of the same characteristics as American jihadist terrorists: losers who attached themselves to extremist right-wing ideologies that gave meaning to their otherwise dead-end lives.
Consider some well-known American jihadist terrorists. Tamerlan Tsarnaev and his younger brother Dzhokhar blew up bombs killing three spectators at the Boston Marathon in 2013. At the time of the bombings, Tamerlan was unemployed and unemployable. His dreams of being an Olympic-level boxer had long faded and the heroic figure that his family had once looked up to was now sitting on his couch at home, wholly dependent on his wife, who was working 80 hours a week. By becoming a jihadist, Tamerlan was in his own mind once again the heroic figure that he fervently believed himself to be.
Consider also Nidal Hasan, who killed 13 at the Fort Hood army base in Texas in 2009. Hasan was about to turn forty, and he was unmarried and almost entirely friendless. He was a mediocre army officer who had recently been ordered to go to Afghanistan, which he was very worried about. On his business cards, Hasan had printed the words “SOA,” which was short for “Soldier of Allah.” Hasan secretly saw himself as a holy warrior, and the massacre at Fort Hood was his twisted way of becoming that warrior he dreamed of being.
American forensic psychologist Reid Meloy, together with Jessica Yakeley, published a 2014 study of terrorists such as Hasan, people who were not part of a formal terrorist organization. They found that they started with a “grievance” that was often “an event or series of events that involve loss and often humiliation of the subject. … Such intense grievances require that individuals take no personal responsibility for their failures in life … they are ‘injustice collectors.'”
Meloy, who has consulted with the FBI, explains that what often follows the grievance is “moral outrage,” which is embedded “in an historical, religious or political cause or event.” Grievance and moral outrage are then “framed by an ideology,” but the ideology is secondary; it functions as rationale for the terrorist to carry out the violent act he is planning. Meloy explains, “This framing is absolutist and simplistic, providing a clarity that both rationalizes behavior and masks other, more personal grievances.”
This seems like an almost perfect description of Cesar Sayoc, 56, of Aventura, Florida who had led an itinerant life as a sometime male dancer, occasional DJ at a strip club, and pizza delivery guy. At the time of his arrest, Sayoc was living out of a van plastered with images of President Donald Trump and of some of Trump’s critics with targets over their faces. Sayoc also posted virulently anti-Muslim messages on the Internet.
Sayoc was arrested Friday by the FBI after he had allegedly sent 15 crude bombs to prominent Democrats, former officials and CNN. The bombs didn’t explode.
Robert Bowers, the man accused of gunning down 11 at the Pittsburgh synagogue, fits the same profile as Sayoc. According to the New York Times, Bowers lived in a “shabby one-bedroom” apartment and was “an isolated, awkward man who lived alone and struggled with basic human interactions.”
Bowers had posted multiple anti-Semitic and anti-immigrant posts on Gab, a social media network, before he carried out the massacre at the synagogue. Bowers frequently posted conspiracy theories about the migrant march now wending its way through Mexico to the United States, which is a major preoccupation of Trump supporters.
For his assault, Bowers used the weapon of choice for mass shooters in the United States: the AR-15, a semi-automatic rifle that is a perfect weapon to kill lots of people.
What to do about these lone terrorists who are unconnected to formal jihadist organizations or to right-wing extremist groups? The obvious start would be tightening gun laws around semi-automatic weapons that are designed to kill other human beings. My in-laws in Louisiana do not go deer hunting with AR-15s.
But good luck with that, as the NRA has killed the most modest gun control measures, even in the wake of the 2016 Pulse nightclub massacre in Orlando, in which 49 were killed by another loser-turned-jihadist, Omar Mateen. Mateen had legally purchased semi-automatic weapons, despite the fact that he had been interviewed twice by the FBI because of his jihadist sympathies.
So, we will continue to live in country where massacres by American jihadist terrorists and right-wing extremists, enabled by the laxest gun laws in the West, will be a regular feature of American life. Pity that the right to life of their many victims is outweighed by the Second Amendment absolutists at the NRA.
The truth is that zeros wanting to be heroes, motivated by a number of toxic ideologies and armed with semi-automatic weapons, will likely continue to massacre Americans at frequent intervals for the foreseeable future.
U.S. Edition+
The global fallout from the Khashoggi murder is bad news for the Saudis
By Peter Bergen, CNN National Security Analyst
Updated 8:21 AM ET, Thu November 1, 2018
Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is the author of “United States of Jihad: Investigating America’s Homegrown Terrorists.”
Doha, Qatar
(CNN)The murder of Jamal Khashoggi in Istanbul four weeks ago has severely damaged the reputation of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, who has been a favorite of the Trump administration.
It seems unlikely that President Trump will do anything especially substantive to punish the Saudis for the murder, since Trump has repeatedly pointed to the purported $110 billion of arms sales he has secured from Saudi Arabia as a rationale for maintaining close ties with the kingdom. (Here, Trump is making the mistake of believing his own propaganda, because, thus far, only a small fraction of those sales is actually happening.)
Trump also needs the Saudis as allies for his anti-Iran policy, and because it is the largest exporter of oil in the world and therefore has the power to set oil prices.
Even if the Trump administration doesn’t do much to punish Saudi Arabia, that doesn’t mean there isn’t already global fallout for Mohammed bin Salman, widely known as MBS.
Potential investors in Saudi Arabia were already unsettled last year when MBS imprisoned some two hundred businessmen and princes on charges of supposed corruption. They were held at the Ritz Carlton in the Saudi capital, Riyadh, and freed only after more than $35 billion were extracted from them, according to MBS himself in an interview with Bloomberg News. This surely must be the most expensive hotel bill in history.
The murder of Khashoggi, and the Saudi government’s multiple, implausible accounts about his fate, served to underscore MBS’s previous rash moves. His botched invasion of Yemen in 2015 has helped to precipitate the worst humanitarian crisis in the world, according to the UN. Last year MBS also launched the blockade of neighboring gas-rich Qatar, and presided over the bizarre de facto abduction and short-lived “resignation” of the Lebanese prime minister when he was visiting the kingdom.
Because of Khashoggi’s murder, MBS’s grandiose “Davos in the Desert” conference in Saudi Arabia a week ago was a damp squib, with many leading businessmen and all Western media organizations pulling out of the event.
That is likely to have some real effects on MBS’s ambitious “Vision 2030” plan to diversify the economy of Saudi Arabia. While defense contractors and oil companies will likely conduct business as usual with the kingdom, the other investors that MBS was hoping to attract to transform the heavily oil-dependent Saudi economy are much less likely to do business with it.
British billionaire Richard Branson, for instance, has suspended his involvement in two tourism projects in Saudi Arabia, as well as discussions about a possible $1 billion Saudi investment in his space ventures.
After Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan officially confirmed Khashoggi’s murder last week, the Trump administration signaled that its long acquiescence in the conduct of the Saudi-led war in Yemen has finally evaporated. According to the UN, at least 16,000 civilians have died in the past three years in Yemen, mostly in airstrikes attributed to the Saudis.
On Tuesday, US Secretary of Defense James Mattis called for a ceasefire in Yemen, leading to peace talks within a month, as did US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo.
In Congress, members who are concerned by the Saudi conduct of the war in Yemen are calling to end American intelligence support to the Saudis, and to end US aerial refueling for Saudi aircraft involved in the conflict. If the Democrats take the House in the midterm election on November 6, those calls are only likely to amplify.
The skepticism about the Saudis is now bipartisan; on Wednesday a group of Republican senators asked Trump to suspend negotiations over a US-Saudi civil nuclear agreement because of concerns about the conduct of the war in Yemen and the murder of Khashoggi.
The blockade of Qatar
The small state of Qatar sits on some of the largest natural gas reserves in the world. It is also home to the largest US military base in the Middle East, which coordinates the wars against ISIS and the Taliban and is also the launchpad for airstrikes against these groups.
According to a former US official with knowledge of the basing arrangement in Qatar, the Qataris pay 90% of the costs for the base, the kind of deal that Trump should have found to his liking — an American base almost entirely paid for by another country.
Qatar also houses regional hubs of several leading American universities, such as Georgetown and Cornell.
So it was surprising that President Trump endorsed the Saudi-led blockade of Qatar when it began last June. This came shortly after Trump had made his first overseas trip as President to Saudi Arabia, where he was treated to a fawning welcome.
As the blockade got underway, Trump immediately aligned himself with Saudi talking points about Qatar, tweeting, “So good to see the Saudi Arabia visit with the King and 50 countries already paying off. They said they would take a hard line on funding……extremism, and all reference was pointing to Qatar. Perhaps this will be the beginning of the end to the horror of terrorism!”
Joshua Geltzer, the former senior director for counterterrorism at the National Security Council for both President Obama and President Trump, says that, in fact, “The Qataris were generally important counterterrorism partners. The biggest sticking point was the terrorism financing issue. My sense is that they’ve realized over time the concerns about that and are working to tighten up their approach to that critical aspect of dealing with the terrorism challenge.” (Geltzer is a fellow at New America, where I also work.)
Belatedly, Trump realized that the blockade of Qatar made little sense from an American national security perspective and tried to put pressure on the Saudis to lift it, so far to no avail.
Today, Qatar looks like a far more natural ally for the United States than the Saudis. Qatar has the second highest per capita income in the world and, by Gulf standards, it has a relaxed approach to social mores. It is also home to the Al Jazeera television network, which is one of the few independent sources of news in the Arab world.
And it continues to house the most important US military base in the Middle East.
Qatar is also hosting an office for the Taliban. After 17 years of war with no end in sight in Afghanistan, the Trump administration has proven willing — perhaps surprisingly — to enter into direct negations with the Taliban, which are taking place in Qatar.
The Qataris seemed to have weathered the blockade well. At one point they feared it was a prelude to a military invasion by their much larger neighbor, Saudi Arabia. That hasn’t happened.
Now it is the Saudis who have to worry about how the rest of the world sees them and deals with them, despite their key importance to global oil markets. It’s just one of the unexpected consequences of their murder of a journalist in a Saudi consulate in Istanbul.
Pai
Trump’s uncritical embrace of MBS set the stage for Khashoggi crisis
Trump’s uncritical embrace of MBS set the stage for Khashoggi crisis
By Peter Bergen, CNN National Security Analyst
Updated 6:30 PM ET, Mon October 15, 2018
Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is writing a book for Penguin/Random House about the national security decision-making of the Trump administration and has reported frequently from Saudi Arabia since 2005.
(CNN)In Saudi Arabia in May 2017, President Donald Trump, his son-in-law Jared Kushner and key members of the US Cabinet were treated to a royal, red carpet visit designed to appeal to Trump’s fetish for being fawned over, featuring elaborate, ceremonial sword dances in a blinged out, opulent palace that made Trump Tower look relatively modest.
Trump more than returned the favor, delivering a speech in the Saudi capital, Riyadh, in which he told the leaders of the Gulf States and other Muslim heads of state that he wasn’t going to hassle them about human rights, declaring, “We are not here to lecture—we are not here to tell other people how to live, what to do, who to be…”
That speech turned out to be a green light for the wild adventures of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, starting with an illegal blockade of Qatar two weeks later. Under bin Salman’s growing control of the Saudi state, the hands-off American policy has continued, despite a humanitarian nightmare in Yemen, the seeming extortion of Saudi oligarchs of tens of billions of dollars and, if the allegations of Turkish officials are to be believed, the murder and dismemberment of a prominent Saudi writer inside the Saudi consulate in Istanbul.
The mysterious disappearance of Washington Post contributor Jamal Khashoggi, raises important questions, not only about the nature of the Saudi regime, but also about the Trump administration’s uncritical embrace of its 33-year-old Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, a close alliance that was engineered by President Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, who was awarded the Middle East portfolio during the presidential transition.
On the campaign trail Trump had repeatedly denounced the Iranian nuclear agreement negotiated by the Obama administration as “the worst deal ever.” This stance very much aligned with the views of the Gulf States, led by the Saudis, who felt that President Obama was empowering Iran at their expense.
Like much of the rest of the world, though, the Saudis didn’t expect Trump to win the presidential election. When he did, the Saudis and their close allies the Emiratis had to scramble to build bridges to the Trump team.
Through intermediaries such as billionaire businessmen Thomas Barrack, a close friend of Trump who has worked in the Arab world for decades, as well as the longtime Emirati ambassador to the United States, Yousef al-Otaiba, Kushner was put in touch with Mohammed bin Salman, according to the New York Times.
T
Mohammed bin Salman’s 82-year-old father, King Salman, is monarch in name, but it’s clear that his son, who is widely known as MBS, is the center of power in the Saudi kingdom.
Both the scions of enormously wealthy, powerful families and only a few years apart in age, Kushner and MBS bonded over a belief they could transform the Middle East. They sometimes communicated through the secure WhatsApp messaging app that is used by members of the Saudi royal court, according to a Saudi source close to the royal family.
The Saudi royal family believed they could do business with the Trump family and vice versa, and the Saudis felt that Kushner spoke for the president.
For his part, Kushner believed that MBS could help deliver a US-brokered solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and that their personal relationship could achieve what decades of professional diplomacy hadn’t achieved.
What’s more, Trump, who had campaigned on a promise of excluding Muslim immigrants from the United States, could use some Arab allies, while the Trump administration and the Gulf States were in lock step in their deep suspicion of the Iranian regime.
On March 14, 2017, early in the Trump administration, when MBS was still only the deputy crown prince, he had lunch with President Trump and his top national security advisers at the White House, an unusual honor for someone who was not a head of state and not even the next in line to the throne, which at the time was MBS’s cousin, Mohamed bin Nayef.
That White House lunch helped to tee up Trump’s first overseas trip, which was to Saudi Arabia. Traditionally, American presidents make their first overseas trip to close, democratic allies such as Canada, but in a coup for the Saudis, the honor went to them.
Two weeks after Trump’s trip to Riyadh, the Saudis led an Arab blockade of gas-rich Qatar, closing all border crossings and cutting off air and sea travel.
This was a long-term goal of the Saudis who have long found their enormously wealthy, tiny neighbor to be an irritant because it hosts the TV network, Al Jazeera, which is often critical of other Arab states, and because it is sympathetic to Islamist movements such as the Muslim Brotherhood.
Trump cheered on the blockade, tweeting, “So good to see the Saudi Arabia visit with the King and 50 countries already paying off. They said they would take a hard line on funding……extremism, and all reference was pointing to Qatar. Perhaps this will be the beginning of the end to the horror of terrorism!”
This was the green light that the Saudis needed to keep up the blockade that continues to this day. In international law, a blockade is an act of war.
When Trump made his celebratory tweet about the blockade, he seemed to have no idea that Qatar housed the largest US base in the Middle East, which was also the most important base in the counter-ISIS fight, a base that is almost entirely paid for by the Qataris, according to a US diplomatic source.
The two members of the Trump cabinet who had had extensive dealings with the Qataris objected to the blockade. Secretary of Defense James Mattis understood the key importance of the base in Qatar for the fight against ISIS, while then-Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, had long experience working with the Qataris when he was the CEO of Exxon. Qatar has the third largest natural gas reserves in the world.
Belatedly understanding the important role that Qatar played in the counter-ISIS fight, Trump later tried to put pressure on the Arab states to lift their blockade, to no avail.
MBS cracks down
A month after Trump’s trip to Riyadh, in a palace coup, MBS forced his cousin Mohammed bin Nayef to step down as Crown Prince. Nayef was long regarded as a safe pair of hands by the CIA because of his aggressive efforts to stamp out al Qaeda in the kingdom when he was the Minister of the Interior.
After removing his cousin as Crown Prince and making himself the heir apparent, MBS also set out to remove all other possible challenges to his total grip on power using a Stalinist playbook, minus the gulags.
In November, some 200 wealthy businessmen and princes were famously jailed in the Ritz Carlton in Riyadh — where six months earlier Trump and Kushner had been royally welcomed — and were only released after they had ponied up many billions of dollars that they had purportedly acquired through corruption.
Corruption is an odd charge in Saudi Arabia where there is so little separation between the ruling family and the resources of the state that it is the only country in the world where the ruling family has named an entire country after itself, while MBS thinks nothing of buying expensive gifts for himself, such as a half-billion dollar yacht.
MBS has also imprisoned a range of clerics and civil society activists, some of whom face possible death sentences.
In February, MBS fired much of the leadership of the Saudi military and replaced them with his own picks.
Saudi adventurism abroad
In the past, the invariably geriatric Saudi monarch presided over a conservative foreign policy that was characterized by doing little overseas. MBS by contrast is intervening around the Middle East, not only by leading the blockade of Qatar, but also by starting a war in Yemen. In 2015, MBS began a campaign in Yemen that has helped to precipitate what the UN described earlier this year as the worst humanitarian crisis in the world.
The Trump administration has largely turned a blind eye to the Saudi conduct of its war in Yemen, despite the fact that the Saudi war effort is dependent, in part, on American intelligence and the US aerial refueling of their jet fighters.
In September, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo certified to Congress that the Saudis were trying to reduce civilian casualties in Yemen, a move that was intended to avert any congressional action to stop American support for the Saudis in Yemen.
Last week, however, the UN charged the Saudi-led coalition with killing 1,300 children in air strikes in Yemen over the past three years.
In November MBS forced the Lebanese Prime Minister Saad Hariri, who is a dual Lebanese-Saudi citizen, to announce his resignation when he was visiting Saudi Arabia. MBS believed that Hariri was in the pocket of Iran-backed Hezbollah, which is a major political force in Lebanon. Hariri eventually returned to Lebanon, as prime minister and MBS’s play backfired badly because Hezbollah and Hariri both emerged stronger after this strange episode.
In addition to supporting their war in Yemen, the Trump administration delivered on another key Saudi foreign policy goal on May 8 when Trump announced he was pulling the United States out of the Iran nuclear deal, a move that was applauded by the Saudis.
Their celebration was short-lived, however, because a week later the United States moved its embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem.
The Saudi royal family styles itself “The Keeper of the Holy Places.” The third holiest site in Islam is the Dome of the Rock on Temple Mount in Jerusalem where the Prophet Mohammed is supposed to have ascended into heaven. By moving the US embassy to Jerusalem, the Trump administration signaled it was prepared to ignore Muslim sentiments about the special status of Jerusalem. And with that move any hope that Kushner had that MBS would help him broker an Israeli-Palestinian peace deal was likely dead in the water.
Was the bet on MBS worth it?
On Sunday, on CBS’s “60 Minutes,” Trump promised “severe punishment” for the Saudis if it is proven that they murdered Jamal Khashoggi as Turkish officials have alleged anonymously to media organizations.
Trump, however, said, “we would be punishing ourselves” by canceling US arms sales to Saudi Arabia, a deal which he has frequently trumpeted as amounting to $110 billion.
This is an excellent example of the dangers of believing your own propaganda because, in reality, as a detailed fact check of this claim by the Washington Post has shown, so far only $4 billion of arms sales to the Saudis have been approved by the US State Department since Trump traveled to Riyadh last year. It remains to be seen if additional arms sales will be approved, but for the moment the sales are considerably smaller than was announced when Trump was in Riyadh more than a year ago.
The Trump administration could sanction specific Saudis involved in Khashoggi’s assassination if it is proven that he was assassinated and certainly would be pressured to do by Congress. But Trump is unlikely to do much more given the fact that the Saudis are an important block to Iran’s regional ambitions, an interest shared with the Trump administration.
The last thing Washington would want is to see the Saudis move closer to Russian President Vladimir Putin. MBS recently visited Moscow for the World Cup. One of Trump’s defenses of the arms sales deal with the Saudis is that if US doesn’t do business with the Saudis, someone else like Russia will.
The Saudis must feel pretty good about what they have extracted from the Trump administration: A free hand to wage war in Yemen with American support; the isolation of their arch nemesis, Iran; acquiescence to their blockade of Qatar, and a warm embrace from the President.
In return, the Trump administration has secured some relatively small-scale arms deals and Kushner is more than likely to emerge empty handed with his much-vaunted and long-awaited Israeli-Palestinian peace plan.
There is a useful Yiddish word for what this all amounts to: bupkis.
Central Asia Program
Facebook
Twitter
Youtube
Linkedin
Tue
2018
GW’s Central Asia Program and RFE/RL are happy to announce Not In Our Name
Oct 16 @ 2:30 PM – 6:00 PM
GW’s Central Asia Program and RFE/RL are happy to announce Not In Our Name @ Lindner Family Commons (602)
According to recent estimates, countries of the former Soviet Union are the largest single source of foreign fighters in the Syria/Iraq conflict – more than neighboring states in the Middle East. Although they share no cultural or language ties to Syria or Iraq, it is estimated that more than 4,200 Central Asians have joined the conflict. Communities across the region will feel the effects for decades as those exposed to the horrors of war and extremist ideology return. The challenge Central Asian communities face from extremist groups is real, but so is their determination to fight back on a social and state level.
Not In Our Name, produced by Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (RFE/RL), is the first regional counter-extremism project ever produced for Central Asia. Staff traveled to diverse areas within the region, exploring and reporting on how residents can work together at the local and national level to prevent the spread of violence and extremism. This unique project collected video portraits of individuals who lost family members in Syria and Iraq, and presented those portraits to young people from Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan and Tajikistan, asking them to share their experiences and perspectives.
RFE/RL’s goal is to use journalism to empower communities to stand up to violent extremist recruiters that claim to represent them. Town halls were held in each country with two different audiences–those directly affected by extremist recruiting and those who have not been impacted. A final session brings all participants together to share their very different experiences and learn from one another.
Uzbek, Kazakh, Tajik, and Kyrgyz participants from all ten town halls agreed there are no simple answers. This film follows them as they come to a deeper understanding of the challenges they face and consider what they can do together to form strong communities that take a stand and declare Not In Our Name.
2:30-3:30pm. Panel 1. Research Results
Noah Tucker (Executive Editor Not In Our Name and CAP associate), Serik Besseimbaev (Lead Project Moderator, Project Design Consultant Not In Our Name), Asel Murzakulova (Project Deputy Editor, Producer Not In Our Name)
3:30-4:10pm. Film screening
4:10-4:30pm. Coffee-break
4:30-6:00pm. Panel 2. Violent Extremist Mobilization in Global Context: What Works (and What Doesn’t) to Prevent Recruiting?
Peter Bergen (New America Foundation), Daniel Kimmage (Global Engagement Center, US Department of State), Haroon Ullah (US Agency for Global Media/BBG)
Registration for this event is required.
To apply
Seminar – Harvard Faculty, Fellows, Staff, and Students
“The Future of Jihad,” with Peter Bergen and Lt. Gen. Abdulwahab al-Saedi
RSVP
Wed., Oct. 17, 2018 | 12:00pm – 1:30pm
John F. Kennedy School of Government – Littauer Building, Belfer Center Library, Room L369
Series
Intelligence Seminar Series
The Intelligence Project an Saudi & GCC Security Project will host a lunch seminar with Peter Bergen and Lieutenant General Abdulwahab al-Saedi, on Wednesday, October 17th from 12:00-1:30pm in the Belfer Center Library (L369).
Lunch will be provided. Admission will be on a first come, first served basis.
RSVP to event
Add to Calendar
Share
Lt. General Abdul-Wahab al-Saadi, commander for the Iraqi counterterrorism forces’ operation to re-take Fallujah from Islamic State militants, speaks at a military camp outside Fallujah, Iraq, Monday, June 27, 2016.
CNN
Lt. General Abdul-Wahab al-Saadi, commander for the Iraqi counterterrorism forces’ operation to re-take Fallujah from Islamic State militants, speaks at a military camp outside Fallujah, Iraq, Monday, June 27, 2016.
About
Speakers Biographies
Contact
What is the next evolution of Islamic terrorism?
Please join the Intelligence Project and the Saudi & GCC Security Project for a lunch seminar with Peter Bergen and Lt. Gen Abdulwahab al-Saedi on “The Future of Jihad.” Mr. Bergen and General al-Saedi will discuss the underlying problems in the Middle East that led to the rise of Daesh, and continue to exist today, that will surely produce a so-called “son of ISIS”.
Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is the author of “United States of Jihad: Investigating America’s Homegrown Terrorists.” In 1997, as a producer for CNN, Bergen produced bin Laden’s first television interview, in which he declared war against the United States for the first time to a Western audience.
Lieutenant General Abdulwahab al-Saedi (Arabic: عبد الوهاب الساعديالفريق الركن) is the Deputy Commander of the Iraqi Counter-Terrorism Command. Since 2008, Al-Saedi has been a key leader in the war against Iraqi-based terrorist groups. He was the Operations Commander of Iraqi military forces from 2014 through 2015, overseeing critical Iraqi victories in the battle for Baiji oil fields and the Second Battle of Tikrit. In 2016, al-Saedi led the operation to liberate the city of Fallujah from ISIS forces. Subsequently, in 2017, he led Iraqi Counter-Terrorism forces successful effort to defeat ISIS in Mosul. Al-Saedi has never lost a battle that he commanded.
https://www.cnn.com/2017/12/15/opinions/it-wasnt-trump-but-this-generals-elite-soldiers-who-defeated-isis-bergen/index.html
The totalitarian prince: Trump’s questionable friend in the Middle East
By Peter Bergen, CNN National Security Analyst
\
Prominent Saudi journalist missing in Turkey 02:25
“Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He has been a frequent visitor to Saudi Arabia since 2005.”
(CNN)The mysterious disappearance of Saudi writer and Washington Post contributor Jamal Khashoggi after he entered the Saudi consulate in Istanbul last week has cast a spotlight on the Saudi regime, which is dominated by 33-year-old Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (known commonly as MBS).
This, in turn, raises questions about the nature of the big bet that the Trump administration has placed on the Crown Prince.
For every positive move that MBS has made — giving women the right to drive, allowing concerts in his kingdom, trying to open up the statist, oil-dependent Saudi economy and curtailing the powers of the feared religious police — he has also accumulated a long list of errors.
The Saudi military intervention in neighboring Yemen that began in 2015, has, to put it mildly, not been a success. Houthi rebels there have grown closer to Iran, Yemen remains in the grips of a deadly humanitarian crisis and thousands of civilians have been killed in the conflict.
After more than a year, the blockade of Qatar by a number of Arab states, in which the Saudis are a key player, remains in a standoff with no end in sight. In international law, a blockade amounts to an act of war. Qatar is seeking arbitration of the matter at the United Nations, but adjudicating these kind of cases can take years.
Complicating matters, Turkey is aligned with Qatar against the Arab states involved in the blockade and, if the Saudis have murdered Khashoggi on Turkish soil, as anonymous Turkish officials have alleged to the Washington Post, regional tensions will be further inflamed. Saudi officials have denied this allegation.
But those are not the only countries in the region that MBS has upset. MBS clumsily forced the Lebanese Prime Minister Saad Hariri, who is a dual Lebanese-Saudi citizen, to announce his resignation when he was visiting Saudi Arabia last November. MBS believed that Hariri was too deferential to Hezbollah, which is a significant political force in Lebanon, as well as a client of Iran. Hariri eventually reversed himself and returned to Lebanon. The whole MBS ploy backfired, as both Hariri and Hezbollah emerged stronger after the bizarre episode.
Also, in November, MBS ordered the detention of hundreds of businessmen and princes on allegations of corruption. Imprisoned in the luxurious confines of the Ritz Carlton in Riyadh, they were gradually released in what looked like a shakedown rather than any genuine legal process — but only after huge sums of money had been extracted from them, according to the New York Times. The Saudi government has denied any wrongdoing.
MBS has also arrested a host of innocuous civil society activists, a number of whom face a possible death penalty. They range from Shia activists hoping for greater rights for the Shia minority in the kingdom, such as Israa al-Ghomgham, a 29-year-old woman, to Salman al-Oudah, a prominent 61-year-old cleric with over 14 million Twitter followers .
Despite giving women the right to drive, in May of this year, MBS arrested some of the key women who had led the movement to allow women to drive. At the time, Khashoggi commented, “It’s a war on activism. He wants the people to step aside and accept what he is giving them and he will lead them into the future.”
Why is MBS doing all of this? Because he is moving Saudi Arabia toward a totalitarian dictatorship in which all aspects of society are controlled by him and all forms of dissent are stifled, an approach which is further reinforced by the disappearance of Khashoggi. It’s an old playbook going back to Louis XIV of France, who is thought to have said, “L’état, c’est moi,” which means, “I am the state.”
This is of particular concern given the Trump administration’s warm embrace of MBS. Trump made his first overseas presidential trip to Saudi Arabia. Usually, American presidents make their first presidential trips to close democratic allies. But Trump views Saudi Arabia as the principal bulwark in the Middle East against Iran, while his son-in-law Jared Kushner has hopes that MBS will play a key role in settling the Israeli-Palestinian dispute.
\
Since then, the Trump administration has made little effort to critique the Saudi kingdom, neither for the thousands of civilian casualties in Yemen, nor its imprisonment of businessmen, royals, clerics and civil society activists at home.
On Monday, Trump did say he was “concerned” about Khashoggi’s disappearance. Meanwhile, Saudi Arabia’s ambassador to the United States, Prince Khalid bin Salman, who is MBS’s brother, said claims that Khashoggi had been killed in Istanbul were “absolutely false, and baseless.”
If evidence emerges that Khashoggi was indeed murdered in Istanbul, US sanctions should be levied on the kingdom.
The Trump administration properly put sanctions on Russia earlier this year after evidence showed that a former Russian agent and his daughter living in the United Kingdom were the targets of a Russian assassination plot using a nerve agent. Why should the Saudis be treated differently?
By Peter Bergen, CNN National Security Analyst
“Peter Bergen is CNN’s national security analyst, a vice president at New America and a professor of practice at Arizona State University. He is the author of “The Osama bin Laden I Know: An Oral History of al-Qaeda’s Leader.” See more opinion at CNN.”
(CNN)Jamal Khashoggi, a prominent Saudi writer, vanished on Tuesday after entering the Saudi consulate in Istanbul to obtain paperwork so he could marry his Turkish fiancée. He has not been seen or heard from since.
As a columnist for the Washington Post, Khashoggi was a frequent critic of the Saudi regime. Khashoggi was living in self-imposed exile in the United States.
On Saturday, Turkish officials told the Washington Post that Khashoggi was murdered at the Saudi consulate.
CNN has not been able to independently confirm these reports and a Saudi official has denied them.
Earlier in the week, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman had told Bloomberg News that Khashoggi had left the consulate unmolested, but if that was the case, why hasn’t he contacted anyone?
Media outlets around the world have reported on Khashoggi’s mysterious disappearance. If Khashoggi had left the consulate unharmed, it’s inconceivable he wouldn’t have informed his fiancée, family, friends and colleagues at the Washington Post.
I have known Khashoggi for more than a decade and am appalled at the possibility that the Saudi government would engineer the disappearance of a writer who worked tirelessly to promote civilized, humane values.
Khashoggi and bin Laden’s paths diverged
I first came to know Khashoggi when I was reporting on Osama bin Laden. As young men, Khashoggi and bin Laden knew each other well because Khashoggi was the first journalist from a major Arab news organization to profile bin Laden when he was fighting the Soviets in Afghanistan in the late 1980s. Both men were idealistic and religious and were opposed to the communist invasion of a Muslim country and the brutal tactics of the Soviet military.
On May 4, 1988, Khashoggi wrote a story for Arab News that quoted bin Laden as saying, “It was God alone who protected us from the Russians during their offensive last year. Reliance upon God is the main source of our strength.”
Seven years later, when bin Laden was based in Sudan, Khashoggi visited him there. Bin Laden told his old friend that he was thinking of returning to Saudi Arabia and renouncing his war against the Saudi regime. That, of course, didn’t happen — and in 1996 bin Laden moved to Afghanistan, where he launched his war against the United States.
While bin Laden became the world’s most wanted terrorist, Khashoggi went on to have a distinguished career as a writer and editor and also an adviser to Prince Turki al-Faisal, who was the Saudi ambassador to both the United Kingdom and the United States.
The totalitarian regime in Saudi Arabia
The disappearance of Khashoggi is of a piece with much that the Saudi regime of Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is doing.
In 2015, bin Salman, who is often referred to as MBS, launched a war in Yemen in which at least 6,500 civilians have been killed, many of them from Saudi munitions, according to the United Nations in a report that was released in August.
The UN report noted that, “air strikes have hit residential areas, markets, funerals, weddings, detention facilities, civilian boats and even medical facilities.”
The Saudis have also arrested a range of civil society activists and conservative clerics, including some who may face death sentences.
Saudi prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for a 29-year-old Shia female activist accused of organizing demonstrations for greater Shia rights who was arrested in December.
Follow CNN Opinion
Join us on Twitter and Facebook
Similarly, the Saudis are seeking the death penalty for a prominent, reformist cleric, Salman Al-Oudah, who has called for elections in the Saudi kingdom.
Saudi Arabia was once a consensus-based absolute monarchy, but under MBS’s direction it is increasingly becoming a secularizing totalitarian dictatorship.
While there is much to praise in some of what MBS has done, such as removing the feared religious police from the streets and making real efforts to reform the heavily oil-dependent Saudi economy, there is also much that is inexcusable.
There is no hard evidence as yet that Khashoggi was murdered, but if such evidence were to emerge and the Saudis are found to be responsible, the United States should impose sanctions on the Saudis just as the Trump administration did in August against the Russians following their use of a nerve agent to attempt to kill a former Russian agent and his daughter in the United Kingdom.
Khashoggi, after all, was both a legal resident of the United States and was employed by a major American media institution.